1
00:01:02,452 --> 00:01:04,661
Thank you very much, sir.

2
00:01:04,747 --> 00:01:06,914
You did a wonderful job. Wonderful.

3
00:01:06,998 --> 00:01:09,375
Shh. Shh.

4
00:01:09,460 --> 00:01:10,878
We did it, Pete. We did it.

5
00:01:12,964 --> 00:01:14,673
- For a moment, we had our doubts.
- Shh.

6
00:01:14,759 --> 00:01:18,177
To continue, you've listened
to a long and complex case...

7
00:01:18,262 --> 00:01:20,054
murder in the first degree.

8
00:01:20,139 --> 00:01:25,102
A premeditated murder is the most serious
charge tried in our criminal courts.

9
00:01:25,187 --> 00:01:26,937
You've listened to the testimony.

10
00:01:27,022 --> 00:01:29,940
You've had the law read to you
and interpreted as it applies in this case.

11
00:01:30,027 --> 00:01:34,030
It's now your duty to sit down and try
and separate the facts from the fancy.

12
00:01:34,948 --> 00:01:38,494
One man is dead.
Another man's life is at stake.

13
00:01:39,287 --> 00:01:43,291
If there's a reasonable doubt in your minds
as to the guilt of the accused...

14
00:01:43,374 --> 00:01:45,293
a reasonable doubt...

15
00:01:45,377 --> 00:01:48,172
then you must bring me
a verdict of not guilty.

16
00:01:48,255 --> 00:01:50,132
Now if, however,
there's no reasonable doubt...

17
00:01:50,216 --> 00:01:54,095
then you must in good conscience
find the accused guilty.

18
00:01:55,222 --> 00:01:59,352
However you decide,
your verdict must be unanimous.

19
00:01:59,435 --> 00:02:02,813
In the event
that you find the accused guilty...

20
00:02:02,897 --> 00:02:06,234
the bench will not entertain
a recommendation for mercy.

21
00:02:06,319 --> 00:02:09,530
The death sentence
is mandatory in this case.

22
00:02:09,614 --> 00:02:13,326
You're faced with a grave responsibility.
Thank you, gentlemen.

23
00:02:15,328 --> 00:02:17,372
The alternate jurors are excused.

24
00:02:23,380 --> 00:02:25,381
The jury will now retire.

25
00:04:23,397 --> 00:04:25,398
Try this one. See if I can get it...

26
00:04:26,733 --> 00:04:28,485
It's a muggy day.

27
00:04:31,739 --> 00:04:34,117
Hey. Oh, oh.

28
00:04:46,173 --> 00:04:48,258
- Piece of gum?
- No, thanks.

29
00:04:48,342 --> 00:04:50,427
This thing is...

30
00:04:50,512 --> 00:04:52,138
- Huh?
- ...move it.

31
00:04:53,766 --> 00:04:55,933
- Come on, I'll give you a hand.
- Give me a hand with that.

32
00:04:56,018 --> 00:04:57,352
That's it.

33
00:05:02,985 --> 00:05:04,611
- You know something?
- Yeah?

34
00:05:04,695 --> 00:05:06,447
I called the weather bureau this morning.

35
00:05:06,530 --> 00:05:08,448
This is gonna be
the hottest day of the year.

36
00:05:08,533 --> 00:05:10,117
Could be.

37
00:05:10,201 --> 00:05:12,120
Boy, you'd think they'd at least
air-condition these places.

38
00:05:12,203 --> 00:05:15,541
- What is your name, sir?
- Oh, it's, uh - That one, yeah.

39
00:05:15,624 --> 00:05:17,043
Thank you very much.

40
00:05:17,127 --> 00:05:19,880
Okay, gentlemen, everybody's here.

41
00:05:19,963 --> 00:05:22,798
Now, if there's anything you want,
I'll be right outside the door.

42
00:05:22,883 --> 00:05:25,135
- Just knock.
- Okay, thanks. We will.

43
00:05:37,650 --> 00:05:38,859
Good morning.

44
00:05:38,943 --> 00:05:40,403
I never knew they locked the door.

45
00:05:40,487 --> 00:05:42,655
Sure they lock the door.
What'd you think?

46
00:05:43,741 --> 00:05:46,159
I don't know.
It just never occurred to me.

47
00:05:47,788 --> 00:05:49,580
What's that for?

48
00:05:49,664 --> 00:05:51,540
Oh, I thought we might want
to vote by ballot.

49
00:05:51,626 --> 00:05:54,293
Great idea. Maybe we can
get him elected senator.

50
00:05:56,547 --> 00:05:58,299
Just in case, you know.

51
00:06:01,804 --> 00:06:03,930
- Ηow'd you like it?
- Oh, I don't know.

52
00:06:04,014 --> 00:06:05,683
It was pretty interesting.

53
00:06:05,767 --> 00:06:07,726
Yeah? I almost fell asleep.

54
00:06:07,812 --> 00:06:10,396
I mean, I've never been
on a jury before.

55
00:06:10,481 --> 00:06:13,191
No? I've sat on many juries.

56
00:06:14,360 --> 00:06:17,279
What gets me is the way
those lawyers talk and talk and talk...

57
00:06:17,364 --> 00:06:19,533
even when it's an open-and-shut case
like this one.

58
00:06:19,616 --> 00:06:21,325
Did you ever hear
so much talk about nothin'?

59
00:06:21,410 --> 00:06:23,286
Well, I guess they're entitled.

60
00:06:23,371 --> 00:06:25,832
Yeah. They're entitled.
It's the system, but...

61
00:06:27,042 --> 00:06:31,129
If you ask me, I'd slap those tough kids
down before they start any trouble.

62
00:06:31,214 --> 00:06:33,298
It would save us a lot of time and money.

63
00:06:33,382 --> 00:06:34,925
- Hey, let's get started, huh?
- That's a good idea.

64
00:06:35,010 --> 00:06:37,637
- Yeah, let's get goin', huh?
- We probably all got things to do here.

65
00:06:37,720 --> 00:06:40,765
I figured we'd start out with a five-minute break.
There's one gentleman in the bathroom.

66
00:06:40,850 --> 00:06:41,808
- Mr. Foreman.
- Huh?

67
00:06:41,893 --> 00:06:44,687
- Are, uh - Are we gonna sit in order?
- Gee, I don't know.

68
00:06:44,771 --> 00:06:46,522
I, uh - Well, I guess so.

69
00:06:51,530 --> 00:06:52,988
Uh, you're in my seat.

70
00:06:53,072 --> 00:06:55,074
- Oh. Excuse me.
- That's all right.

71
00:06:57,619 --> 00:06:59,370
Hey, that's not a bad view, huh?

72
00:07:03,001 --> 00:07:05,461
What did you think of the case?

73
00:07:05,546 --> 00:07:07,589
I mean, it had a lot of interest for me.

74
00:07:07,673 --> 00:07:10,801
No real... dead spots.
You know what I mean?

75
00:07:11,677 --> 00:07:14,138
I tell you, we were lucky
to get a murder case.

76
00:07:14,222 --> 00:07:16,182
I figured us for an assault or burglary.

77
00:07:16,267 --> 00:07:18,518
Boy, they can be the dullest.

78
00:07:20,104 --> 00:07:21,397
Hey.

79
00:07:21,480 --> 00:07:23,065
That the Woolworth Building?

80
00:07:23,149 --> 00:07:25,067
That's right.

81
00:07:25,152 --> 00:07:26,736
Isn't that funny?

82
00:07:26,819 --> 00:07:29,197
You know, I've lived here all my life.
I've never been inside that.

83
00:07:29,282 --> 00:07:31,366
If you had to sort out all that junk...

84
00:07:31,451 --> 00:07:33,535
Like that thing with the movies.

85
00:07:33,620 --> 00:07:36,623
- Yeah. You can say that again.
- And what about that business with the knife?

86
00:07:36,707 --> 00:07:39,584
I mean, asking grown-up people
to believe that kind of jazz, huh?

87
00:07:39,668 --> 00:07:42,129
Well, I expected that.
You know what we're dealing with.

88
00:07:42,215 --> 00:07:44,674
Yeah, I guess so.

89
00:07:44,758 --> 00:07:46,467
Well, your horn works.
Now try your lights.

90
00:07:48,138 --> 00:07:49,596
- What do you got, a cold?
- And how.

91
00:07:49,680 --> 00:07:51,891
These hot-weather colds can kill you.

92
00:07:51,974 --> 00:07:54,393
I can hardly touch my nose.
You know what I mean?

93
00:07:54,478 --> 00:07:58,022
I sure do. I just got over one.

94
00:07:58,107 --> 00:08:00,859
Aw, come on. Mr.
Foreman, let's go here, huh?

95
00:08:00,944 --> 00:08:02,569
Well, that guy's still in the bathroom.

96
00:08:02,655 --> 00:08:05,491
Hey, what's new? I didn't get a chance
to see a paper this morning.

97
00:08:05,574 --> 00:08:06,659
Hmm?

98
00:08:06,742 --> 00:08:09,161
I was only wondering
how the market closed.

99
00:08:09,246 --> 00:08:11,957
You got a seat on the Exchange?

100
00:08:12,040 --> 00:08:13,792
I'm a broker.

101
00:08:13,876 --> 00:08:18,255
I run a messenger service -
the Beck and Call Company.

102
00:08:18,340 --> 00:08:20,466
The name is my wife's idea.

103
00:08:20,549 --> 00:08:24,179
Got 37 men working.
Started with nothing.

104
00:08:24,263 --> 00:08:27,432
Okay, men, let's take our seats, huh?

105
00:08:30,604 --> 00:08:32,438
Yeah, we can all get outta here
pretty quick, huh?

106
00:08:32,523 --> 00:08:35,734
I don't know about the rest of you, but I happen
to have tickets to that ball game tonight.

107
00:08:35,818 --> 00:08:37,653
Yanks and Cleveland.

108
00:08:37,737 --> 00:08:39,530
Yeah, we got this kid,
Modjelewski, in there.

109
00:08:39,615 --> 00:08:41,283
Ooh, he's a real bull, this kid.

110
00:08:41,366 --> 00:08:43,493
You know - Phoom!

111
00:08:43,576 --> 00:08:45,829
A real jug handle. You know?

112
00:08:45,913 --> 00:08:48,165
Phoom!

113
00:08:48,250 --> 00:08:50,584
You're a real baseball fan, aren't you?
Huh? Yeah.

114
00:08:50,670 --> 00:08:52,128
Where do we sit here?

115
00:08:52,213 --> 00:08:55,299
Well, I thought we'd sit in order,
you know, by jury numbers.

116
00:08:55,383 --> 00:08:57,801
One, two, three, four, five -
so on, around the table.

117
00:08:57,886 --> 00:08:59,136
If that's okay with you gentlemen.

118
00:08:59,221 --> 00:09:00,305
- Sure.
- What's the difference?

119
00:09:00,389 --> 00:09:03,434
- I think it's reasonable to sit in order.
- Let it be.

120
00:09:03,517 --> 00:09:05,769
- Number 12. Do I sit down here?
- Yeah. That's 12. We go around...

121
00:09:05,854 --> 00:09:09,106
- We start with you. One, right?
- One, yeah. Two, three, four, five, six.

122
00:09:09,190 --> 00:09:11,526
What was your impression
of the prosecuting attorney?

123
00:09:11,609 --> 00:09:13,319
Okay. Two. You're two.

124
00:09:13,405 --> 00:09:14,572
I beg pardon?

125
00:09:14,655 --> 00:09:18,826
I thought he was really sharp, the way
he handled all those points one by one.

126
00:09:18,910 --> 00:09:22,038
Logical sequence.
I was very impressed.

127
00:09:22,123 --> 00:09:25,126
I think he - he did an expert job.

128
00:09:25,209 --> 00:09:28,212
A lot of drive too, you know?
Real drive.

129
00:09:28,297 --> 00:09:30,381
- Okay, fellas, can we hold it down a minute?
- Sure.

130
00:09:30,466 --> 00:09:32,050
Uh, fellas.

131
00:09:32,135 --> 00:09:35,596
Say, we'd like to get started.
Gentleman at the window.

132
00:09:37,266 --> 00:09:39,433
- We'd like to get started.
- Oh, I'm sorry.

133
00:09:39,519 --> 00:09:43,189
Pretty tough to figure, isn't it?
Kid kills his father - bing, just like that.

134
00:09:43,273 --> 00:09:45,857
Aw, listen, you analyze the figures,
you'll see it happens all the time.

135
00:09:45,943 --> 00:09:47,860
They let those kids
run wild up there.

136
00:09:47,944 --> 00:09:50,655
Well, maybe it serves 'em right.
You know what I mean?

137
00:09:50,740 --> 00:09:52,324
Is - Is everyone here?

138
00:09:52,409 --> 00:09:54,243
The old man is inside.

139
00:09:54,328 --> 00:09:56,954
Oh. Would you, uh,
knock on the door for him?

140
00:09:57,038 --> 00:09:58,998
You a Yankee fan?

141
00:09:59,083 --> 00:10:00,625
No. Baltimore.

142
00:10:01,543 --> 00:10:03,045
- Baltimore?
- Yeah.

143
00:10:04,339 --> 00:10:06,883
That's like being hit in the head
with a crowbar once a day.

144
00:10:08,636 --> 00:10:09,886
Who have they got?

145
00:10:09,970 --> 00:10:12,389
No, I mean, who have they got
besides good groundskeepers?

146
00:10:12,474 --> 00:10:14,016
Say, uh, we'd like to get started.

147
00:10:14,101 --> 00:10:17,145
Oh, forgive me, gentlemen.
I - I didn't mean to keep you waiting.

148
00:10:17,939 --> 00:10:19,731
Baltimore?

149
00:10:19,816 --> 00:10:22,610
Okay, gentlemen,
if I can have your attention.

150
00:10:22,694 --> 00:10:25,655
You fellas can handle this thing
any way that you want to.

151
00:10:25,739 --> 00:10:28,241
I'm, um - You know,
I'm not gonna make any rules.

152
00:10:28,326 --> 00:10:31,620
Uh, we can, well, discuss it first
and, uh, then vote on it.

153
00:10:31,705 --> 00:10:34,374
That's, of course, uh -
That's, uh, one way.

154
00:10:34,457 --> 00:10:37,420
And, uh, well, we can
vote on it right now, and...

155
00:10:37,503 --> 00:10:40,004
I think it's customary
to take a preliminary vote.

156
00:10:40,089 --> 00:10:43,676
Yeah, let's - Let's vote. Who knows?
Maybe we all can get outta here, huh?

157
00:10:43,761 --> 00:10:45,470
Uh-huh.

158
00:10:45,555 --> 00:10:48,640
Okay, then I think that, uh...

159
00:10:48,724 --> 00:10:51,602
Of course you know that we have
a first-degree murder charge here...

160
00:10:51,686 --> 00:10:53,770
and if we vote the accused guilty...

161
00:10:53,857 --> 00:10:57,109
uh, we've got to send him
to the chair.

162
00:10:57,192 --> 00:11:00,946
- Um, that's mandatory.
- I think we know that.

163
00:11:01,031 --> 00:11:02,782
- Let's see who's where.
- We might as well.

164
00:11:02,866 --> 00:11:06,662
- Okay. Uh, anyone doesn't want to vote?
- All right with me.

165
00:11:07,873 --> 00:11:12,461
Okay. Then, uh, just remember that this
has to be 12 to nothing either way.

166
00:11:12,544 --> 00:11:14,004
Um, that's the law.

167
00:11:14,088 --> 00:11:16,131
Okay, are we ready?

168
00:11:16,215 --> 00:11:19,218
Now, all those voting guilty,
please raise your hands.

169
00:11:23,224 --> 00:11:26,726
One, two, three, four,
five, six, seven...

170
00:11:28,062 --> 00:11:30,647
eight, nine, 10, 11.

171
00:11:30,732 --> 00:11:33,652
Okay. That's 11 guilty.

172
00:11:33,736 --> 00:11:35,236
Those voting not guilty.

173
00:11:36,406 --> 00:11:38,492
One. Right.

174
00:11:38,575 --> 00:11:40,869
That's 11 guilty. One not guilty.

175
00:11:41,787 --> 00:11:43,371
Well, now we know where we are.

176
00:11:43,456 --> 00:11:47,626
Boy, oh, boy. There's always one.

177
00:11:48,170 --> 00:11:50,464
So, what do we do now?

178
00:11:50,547 --> 00:11:52,381
Well, I guess we talk.

179
00:11:52,467 --> 00:11:53,799
Boy, oh, boy.

180
00:11:53,885 --> 00:11:55,720
You really think he's innocent?

181
00:11:59,183 --> 00:12:00,725
I don't know.

182
00:12:00,808 --> 00:12:03,686
I mean, you sat in court with the rest of us.
You heard what we did.

183
00:12:03,772 --> 00:12:05,898
The kid's a dangerous killer.
You could see it.

184
00:12:05,982 --> 00:12:07,608
He's 18 years old.

185
00:12:07,692 --> 00:12:09,778
Well, that's old enough. Ηe...

186
00:12:09,862 --> 00:12:12,530
He stabbed his own father
four inches into the chest.

187
00:12:12,616 --> 00:12:14,866
They proved it
a dozen different ways in court.

188
00:12:14,951 --> 00:12:17,496
Would you like me to list them for you?

189
00:12:17,579 --> 00:12:18,871
No.

190
00:12:18,955 --> 00:12:21,041
Then what do you want?

191
00:12:21,125 --> 00:12:24,044
- I just want to talk.
- What's there to talk about?

192
00:12:24,128 --> 00:12:25,463
Eleven men in here think he's guilty.

193
00:12:25,547 --> 00:12:27,798
No one had to think about it twice
except you.

194
00:12:27,884 --> 00:12:31,095
I want to ask you something.
Do you believe his story?

195
00:12:31,179 --> 00:12:33,889
I don't know whether I believe it or not.
Maybe I don't.

196
00:12:33,974 --> 00:12:35,558
So how come you vote not guilty?

197
00:12:35,643 --> 00:12:37,561
Well, there were 11 votes for guilty.

198
00:12:37,645 --> 00:12:40,398
It's not easy to raise my hand
and send a boy off to die...

199
00:12:40,481 --> 00:12:42,566
without talking about it first.

200
00:12:42,650 --> 00:12:45,068
- Well, now, who says it's easy?
- No one.

201
00:12:46,363 --> 00:12:48,532
What, just because I voted fast?

202
00:12:48,615 --> 00:12:51,034
I honestly think the guy's guilty.

203
00:12:51,118 --> 00:12:53,912
You couldn't change my mind
if you talked for a hundred years.

204
00:12:53,998 --> 00:12:55,999
I'm not trying to change your mind.
It's just that...

205
00:12:56,584 --> 00:12:58,836
We're talking about somebody's life here.

206
00:12:58,920 --> 00:13:01,005
We can't decide it in five minutes.
Supposing we're wrong.

207
00:13:01,088 --> 00:13:02,507
"Supposing we're wrong."

208
00:13:02,591 --> 00:13:04,593
Supposing this whole building
should fall down on my head.

209
00:13:04,676 --> 00:13:06,678
- You can suppose anything.
- That's right.

210
00:13:07,513 --> 00:13:09,264
Look, what's the difference
how long it takes?

211
00:13:09,349 --> 00:13:11,933
Suppose we do it in five minutes.
So what?

212
00:13:12,018 --> 00:13:14,145
Let's take an hour.

213
00:13:14,229 --> 00:13:16,148
The ball game doesn't start till 8:00.

214
00:13:18,859 --> 00:13:20,027
Hmm?

215
00:13:22,197 --> 00:13:24,031
Who's got something to say?

216
00:13:24,117 --> 00:13:25,533
I'm willing to sit for an hour.

217
00:13:25,618 --> 00:13:28,328
Great. I heard
a pretty good story last night.

218
00:13:28,412 --> 00:13:30,497
That's not why we're sitting here.

219
00:13:31,207 --> 00:13:34,753
All right, then you tell me.
What are we sitting here for?

220
00:13:36,005 --> 00:13:37,839
I don't know. Maybe no reason.

221
00:13:38,842 --> 00:13:42,303
Look, this kid's been kicked around
all of his life...

222
00:13:42,387 --> 00:13:46,308
you know, born in a slum,
mother dead since he was nine.

223
00:13:46,391 --> 00:13:48,601
He lived for a year and a half
in an orphanage when his...

224
00:13:48,687 --> 00:13:51,606
his father was serving a jail term
for forgery.

225
00:13:51,689 --> 00:13:54,025
It's not a very happy beginning.

226
00:13:54,109 --> 00:13:56,235
He's a - a wild, angry kid.

227
00:13:56,321 --> 00:13:58,030
That's all he's ever been.
And you know why?

228
00:13:58,113 --> 00:14:01,825
'Cause he's been hit on the head
by somebody once a day every day.

229
00:14:01,910 --> 00:14:04,120
He's had a -
He's had a pretty miserable 18 years.

230
00:14:04,205 --> 00:14:07,165
I - I just think we owe him a few words.
That's all.

231
00:14:07,250 --> 00:14:10,795
I don't mind telling you this, mister.
We don't owe him a thing.

232
00:14:10,879 --> 00:14:13,965
He got a fair trial, didn't he?
What do you think that trial cost?

233
00:14:14,050 --> 00:14:17,135
- He's lucky he got it. You know what I mean?
- You know it.

234
00:14:17,220 --> 00:14:19,555
Now, look, we're all grown-ups in here.

235
00:14:19,640 --> 00:14:21,515
We heard the facts, didn't we?

236
00:14:21,601 --> 00:14:25,396
You're not gonna tell me that we're supposed
to believe this kid, knowing what he is.

237
00:14:25,479 --> 00:14:27,856
Listen, I've lived among them
all my life.

238
00:14:27,941 --> 00:14:31,277
You can't believe a word they say.
You know that.

239
00:14:31,362 --> 00:14:33,196
I mean, they're born liars.

240
00:14:33,280 --> 00:14:36,617
- Only an ignorant man can believe that.
- Now listen...

241
00:14:36,701 --> 00:14:39,537
Do you think you were born
with a monopoly on the truth?

242
00:14:39,621 --> 00:14:42,207
I think certain things should be
pointed out to this man.

243
00:14:42,291 --> 00:14:44,376
- Come on. This isn't Sunday.
- We don't need a sermon.

244
00:14:44,459 --> 00:14:46,712
- Come on.
- We have a job to do. Now let's do it.

245
00:14:47,756 --> 00:14:50,800
Rice Pops.
It's a product I work on at the agency.

246
00:14:51,635 --> 00:14:54,263
"The breakfast with the built-in bounce."

247
00:14:54,347 --> 00:14:55,973
- I wrote that line.
- Very catchy.

248
00:14:56,057 --> 00:14:58,226
- Yeah.
- Say, do you mind?

249
00:14:58,310 --> 00:15:00,019
Oh, I'm sorry.

250
00:15:00,103 --> 00:15:02,565
I have this habit of doodling.
Keeps me thinking clearly.

251
00:15:02,648 --> 00:15:04,358
Yeah, we have all this work to do.

252
00:15:04,442 --> 00:15:06,151
- There's no point staying here forever.
- Sorry.

253
00:15:06,236 --> 00:15:08,446
Okay. Um...

254
00:15:08,530 --> 00:15:12,326
perhaps if the gentleman down there
who's disagreeing with us...

255
00:15:12,410 --> 00:15:15,705
Well, perhaps you could tell us why.
You know, let us know what you're thinking.

256
00:15:15,788 --> 00:15:18,166
And we might be able to show you
where you're mixed up.

257
00:15:18,251 --> 00:15:19,918
Well, look, maybe -
Maybe this is an idea.

258
00:15:20,002 --> 00:15:22,421
Now, I haven't given it much thought,
but it seems to me...

259
00:15:22,504 --> 00:15:26,926
that it's up to the group of us to convince
this gentleman that he's wrong and we're right.

260
00:15:27,010 --> 00:15:29,555
Now, maybe if we each took
a couple of minutes just to...

261
00:15:30,973 --> 00:15:32,391
Well, it was just a quick idea.

262
00:15:32,476 --> 00:15:33,934
No, no, no. That's a good one.

263
00:15:34,019 --> 00:15:37,104
Uh, suppose we go
once around the table.

264
00:15:37,190 --> 00:15:40,066
- I guess you're first.
- Oh.

265
00:15:40,151 --> 00:15:41,485
Well, uh...

266
00:15:43,029 --> 00:15:45,448
Well, it-it's hard to put into words.

267
00:15:46,492 --> 00:15:48,494
I just think he's guilty.

268
00:15:48,577 --> 00:15:51,079
I thought it was obvious
from the word "go."

269
00:15:51,164 --> 00:15:52,664
I mean, nobody proved otherwise.

270
00:15:52,749 --> 00:15:54,291
Nobody has to prove otherwise.

271
00:15:54,375 --> 00:15:56,628
The burden of proof's on the prosecution.

272
00:15:56,711 --> 00:15:59,172
The defendant doesn't even
have to open his mouth.

273
00:15:59,257 --> 00:16:02,383
- That's in the Constitution.
- Oh, well, sure, I know that.

274
00:16:02,470 --> 00:16:04,428
Uh, what I meant was, is...

275
00:16:06,223 --> 00:16:08,225
Well, I just think he's guilty.

276
00:16:08,309 --> 00:16:10,018
I-I mean, somebody saw him do it.

277
00:16:10,103 --> 00:16:15,149
Okay. Uh, here's what I think,
and I have no personal feelings about this.

278
00:16:15,234 --> 00:16:17,402
I just want to talk about facts.

279
00:16:18,404 --> 00:16:20,532
Number one.

280
00:16:21,074 --> 00:16:25,203
The old man lived downstairs under the room
where the killing took place.

281
00:16:25,286 --> 00:16:27,414
At 10 minutes after 12:00
on the night of the killing...

282
00:16:27,499 --> 00:16:31,168
he heard loud noises,
said it sounded like a fight.

283
00:16:31,253 --> 00:16:34,129
And he heard the kid yell out,
"I'm gonna kill ya."

284
00:16:34,215 --> 00:16:36,508
A second later,
he heard a body hit the floor.

285
00:16:36,593 --> 00:16:38,301
Ran to the door, opened it up...

286
00:16:38,386 --> 00:16:40,804
saw the kid running down the stairs
and out of the house.

287
00:16:40,889 --> 00:16:42,181
Called the police.

288
00:16:42,266 --> 00:16:44,934
They came in, found the old man
with a knife in his chest.

289
00:16:45,018 --> 00:16:48,273
The coroner fixed the time of death
around midnight.

290
00:16:48,356 --> 00:16:51,442
Now these are facts.
You can't refute facts.

291
00:16:51,527 --> 00:16:53,695
The kid is guilty.

292
00:16:53,779 --> 00:16:55,780
I'm just as sentimental as the next fella.

293
00:16:55,865 --> 00:16:59,743
I know he's only 18, but he's still
gotta pay for what he did.

294
00:16:59,828 --> 00:17:01,288
I'm with you.

295
00:17:01,371 --> 00:17:03,915
Okay. Are you finished?

296
00:17:04,000 --> 00:17:05,458
- Yeah.
- Right. Next.

297
00:17:05,544 --> 00:17:08,754
It is obvious, to me anyway,
that the boy's entire story was flimsy.

298
00:17:08,839 --> 00:17:11,048
He claimed he was at the movies
during the time of the killing...

299
00:17:11,133 --> 00:17:13,677
and yet, one hour later, he couldn't
remember the names of the films he saw...

300
00:17:13,760 --> 00:17:15,596
- or who played in them.
- That's right.

301
00:17:15,681 --> 00:17:17,973
And no one saw him going in
or out of the theater.

302
00:17:18,058 --> 00:17:19,684
Listen, what about the woman
across the street?

303
00:17:19,768 --> 00:17:22,061
If her testimony don't prove it,
nothing does.

304
00:17:22,147 --> 00:17:24,481
That's right. She was the one
who actually saw the killing.

305
00:17:24,566 --> 00:17:26,984
- Now, fellas, please.
- Let's go in order here, huh?

306
00:17:27,068 --> 00:17:30,321
Just a minute. Here's a woman...

307
00:17:30,405 --> 00:17:32,866
Here's a woman who was lying in bed.
She can't sleep.

308
00:17:32,950 --> 00:17:34,869
She's dying with the heat.
You know what I mean?

309
00:17:34,952 --> 00:17:36,786
Anyway, she looks out the window...

310
00:17:36,873 --> 00:17:40,458
and right across the street she sees
the kid stick the knife into his father.

311
00:17:40,543 --> 00:17:43,420
The time is 12:10 on the nose.

312
00:17:43,504 --> 00:17:45,381
Everything fits.

313
00:17:45,465 --> 00:17:47,299
Look, she's known the kid all his life.

314
00:17:47,384 --> 00:17:49,510
His window is right opposite hers
across the el tracks...

315
00:17:49,595 --> 00:17:51,262
and she swore she saw him do it.

316
00:17:51,348 --> 00:17:54,015
- Through the windows of the passing el train.
- Right.

317
00:17:54,100 --> 00:17:58,271
This el train had no passengers on it.
It was just being moved downtown.

318
00:17:58,356 --> 00:18:01,274
The lights were out, remember?
And they proved in court that, at night...

319
00:18:01,359 --> 00:18:03,777
you can look through the windows
of an el train when the lights are out...

320
00:18:03,862 --> 00:18:06,197
and see what's happening
on the other side.

321
00:18:06,281 --> 00:18:09,117
- They proved it.
- I'd like to ask you something.

322
00:18:09,201 --> 00:18:11,871
You don't believe the boy's story.
How come you believe the woman's?

323
00:18:11,955 --> 00:18:13,705
She's one of them too, isn't she?

324
00:18:16,377 --> 00:18:18,378
You're a pretty smart fella, aren't you?

325
00:18:18,462 --> 00:18:19,880
- Okay, gentlemen.
- Now, now.

326
00:18:19,964 --> 00:18:22,174
- Now, gentlemen.
- Come on. Sit down. Sit down.

327
00:18:22,257 --> 00:18:24,803
Oh, what's he so wise about?
I'm telling you.

328
00:18:24,886 --> 00:18:28,139
- Okay, now come on.
- Now we're not gonna get anywhere fighting.

329
00:18:28,224 --> 00:18:29,474
Whose turn is it next?

330
00:18:29,558 --> 00:18:32,395
Oh, uh, his. Number five.

331
00:18:34,648 --> 00:18:37,400
Okay, may I - Can I pass? It...

332
00:18:38,194 --> 00:18:40,237
Well, uh, that's your privilege.

333
00:18:40,321 --> 00:18:43,448
Uh, how about the next gentleman?

334
00:18:43,533 --> 00:18:46,202
Oh. Well, uh, I don't know.

335
00:18:46,285 --> 00:18:50,499
I started to be convinced, you know,
very early in the case.

336
00:18:51,084 --> 00:18:55,213
You see, I was looking for a motive.
That's very important.

337
00:18:55,297 --> 00:18:59,509
Because if you don't have a motive,
where's your case, right?

338
00:18:59,593 --> 00:19:02,680
Anyway, that, uh, testimony
from those people...

339
00:19:02,764 --> 00:19:05,809
in the apartment across the hall
from the kid's apartment...

340
00:19:05,892 --> 00:19:08,145
that was very powerful.

341
00:19:08,229 --> 00:19:11,024
Didn't they say something about a -
a fight and an argument...

342
00:19:11,108 --> 00:19:15,528
between the old man and his son
around about, uh, 7:00 that night?

343
00:19:15,612 --> 00:19:18,072
- I mean, I could be wrong, but I -
- It was 8:00.

344
00:19:18,158 --> 00:19:20,201
It was 8:00. That's right.
They heard an argument.

345
00:19:20,285 --> 00:19:22,036
They couldn't hear what it was about.

346
00:19:22,120 --> 00:19:24,079
Then they heard
the father hit the boy twice.

347
00:19:24,166 --> 00:19:27,125
Finally they saw the boy
run angrily out of the house.

348
00:19:27,210 --> 00:19:28,793
What does that prove?

349
00:19:28,879 --> 00:19:32,548
Well, it don't exactly prove anything.
It's just part of the picture.

350
00:19:32,632 --> 00:19:35,552
Well, you said it provided a motive.
The prosecuting attorney said the same thing.

351
00:19:35,636 --> 00:19:37,888
I don't think
that was a very strong motive.

352
00:19:37,973 --> 00:19:41,560
This boy's been hit so many times in his
life that violence is practically a...

353
00:19:41,643 --> 00:19:44,021
It's a normal state of affairs with him.

354
00:19:44,104 --> 00:19:48,317
I just - I can't see two slaps in the face
provoking him into committing murder.

355
00:19:48,402 --> 00:19:51,988
It may have been two too many.
Everyone has a breaking point.

356
00:19:54,533 --> 00:19:56,618
Anything else?

357
00:19:56,703 --> 00:19:59,164
- No.
- Okay.

358
00:19:59,247 --> 00:20:00,998
Uh, how about you?

359
00:20:02,835 --> 00:20:04,795
I don't know. It's all been said.

360
00:20:06,339 --> 00:20:08,965
You can talk here forever.
It's still the same thing.

361
00:20:10,177 --> 00:20:13,137
This kid is five for 0.

362
00:20:13,223 --> 00:20:15,099
Well, look at his record.

363
00:20:15,182 --> 00:20:17,392
When he was 10,
he was in children's court.

364
00:20:17,477 --> 00:20:19,270
He threw a rock at a teacher.

365
00:20:19,355 --> 00:20:21,648
When he was 15, he was in reform school.

366
00:20:21,732 --> 00:20:23,566
He stole a car.

367
00:20:23,652 --> 00:20:26,153
He's been arrested for mugging.

368
00:20:26,238 --> 00:20:28,239
He was picked up twice for knife fighting.

369
00:20:28,323 --> 00:20:30,407
Oh, yeah, they say
he's real handy with a knife.

370
00:20:30,493 --> 00:20:33,287
Oh, this is a very fine boy.

371
00:20:33,371 --> 00:20:36,373
Ever since he was five years old,
his father beat him up regularly.

372
00:20:36,458 --> 00:20:38,876
- He used his fists.
- Well, so would I.

373
00:20:38,962 --> 00:20:40,461
A kid like that?

374
00:20:40,547 --> 00:20:43,714
It's these kids, the way they are nowadays.

375
00:20:46,219 --> 00:20:49,389
When I was a kid,
I used to call my father "sir."

376
00:20:50,141 --> 00:20:51,433
That's right. "Sir."

377
00:20:51,517 --> 00:20:53,477
Do you ever hear a kid
call his father that any more?

378
00:20:53,562 --> 00:20:56,063
Fathers don't seem to think
it's important any more.

379
00:20:56,857 --> 00:20:58,899
- You got any kids?
- Three.

380
00:21:00,279 --> 00:21:01,611
I got one.

381
00:21:03,115 --> 00:21:04,866
Twenty-two years old.

382
00:21:10,998 --> 00:21:13,750
When he was nine years old,
he ran away from a fight.

383
00:21:15,461 --> 00:21:18,631
I saw it. I was so embarrassed
I almost threw up.

384
00:21:20,302 --> 00:21:24,930
I said, "I'm gonna make a man out of you
if I have to break you in two trying."

385
00:21:27,434 --> 00:21:29,352
Well, I made a man out of him.

386
00:21:30,355 --> 00:21:32,523
When he was 16, we had a fight.

387
00:21:34,109 --> 00:21:36,486
Hit me in the jaw.
He was a big kid.

388
00:21:39,908 --> 00:21:41,992
Haven't seen him for two years.

389
00:21:43,912 --> 00:21:46,206
Kids.

390
00:21:47,917 --> 00:21:49,877
Work your heart out.

391
00:21:52,464 --> 00:21:53,715
Well, let's get going.

392
00:21:53,798 --> 00:21:56,134
I think we're missing the point here.

393
00:21:56,219 --> 00:21:59,638
This boy, let's say he's the product
of a broken home and a filthy neighborhood.

394
00:21:59,723 --> 00:22:03,310
We can't help that. We're here to decide
whether he's innocent or guilty...

395
00:22:03,393 --> 00:22:06,313
not to go into the reasons
why he grew up the way he did.

396
00:22:06,396 --> 00:22:09,107
He was born in a slum.
Slums are breeding grounds for criminals.

397
00:22:09,192 --> 00:22:11,069
I know it, and so do you.

398
00:22:11,152 --> 00:22:15,865
It's no secret children from slum backgrounds
are potential menaces to society.

399
00:22:15,950 --> 00:22:18,117
- Now I think -
- Brother, you can say that again.

400
00:22:18,203 --> 00:22:20,746
The kids who crawl out of these places
are real trash.

401
00:22:20,830 --> 00:22:23,083
- I don't want any part of them. I'm telling you.
- Listen, mister. Listen.

402
00:22:23,167 --> 00:22:26,878
- I, uh - I've lived in a slum all my life.
- Wait a minute.

403
00:22:26,963 --> 00:22:30,383
Please, I - I played in backyards
that were filled with garbage.

404
00:22:30,467 --> 00:22:32,510
I mean, maybe you can still
smell it on me.

405
00:22:32,594 --> 00:22:33,929
Now, listen, sonny.

406
00:22:34,013 --> 00:22:35,597
- Come on now.
- There's nothing personal about this.

407
00:22:35,682 --> 00:22:38,225
- No, there was something personal.
- Aw, come on, fella. He didn't mean you.

408
00:22:38,310 --> 00:22:40,395
Let's not be so sensitive.

409
00:22:40,479 --> 00:22:42,314
This sensitivity I can understand.

410
00:22:42,398 --> 00:22:47,027
Okay, look, let's stop the arguing.
We're only wasting time, and...

411
00:22:48,196 --> 00:22:50,323
Look, your turn down there.
Let's go.

412
00:22:51,659 --> 00:22:54,494
Oh, I didn't expect a turn. I thought
you were all gonna try to convince me.

413
00:22:54,578 --> 00:22:56,329
- Wasn't that the idea?
- Check. That was the idea.

414
00:22:56,415 --> 00:22:58,624
- Oh, I forgot about that. He's right.
- What difference does it make?

415
00:22:58,708 --> 00:23:01,043
He's the one who's keeping us in here.
Let's hear what he's got to say.

416
00:23:01,128 --> 00:23:03,839
Oh, now wait a minute.
We decided to do this a certain way.

417
00:23:03,922 --> 00:23:05,549
I think we ought to stick to that way.

418
00:23:05,634 --> 00:23:07,635
Oh, stop being a kid, will you?

419
00:23:07,720 --> 00:23:09,721
- What do you mean "a kid"?
- What do you think I mean?

420
00:23:09,805 --> 00:23:11,431
K-I-D. Kid.

421
00:23:14,018 --> 00:23:17,689
What? Listen, just because I'm trying
to keep this thing organized?

422
00:23:17,772 --> 00:23:19,899
Here, you take it.
You take on the responsibility.

423
00:23:19,983 --> 00:23:21,860
I'll just - I'll keep my mouth shut.
That's all.

424
00:23:21,944 --> 00:23:23,945
What are you getting so hot about?
Calm down, will you?

425
00:23:24,030 --> 00:23:25,364
Don't tell me to calm down.

426
00:23:25,449 --> 00:23:27,575
Here. You wanna take the chair,
just take the chair. That's all.

427
00:23:27,659 --> 00:23:30,120
- Did you ever see such a thing?
- See if you can keep it running.

428
00:23:30,204 --> 00:23:32,164
- Listen, you think it's funny or something?
- Hey, forget it, fella.

429
00:23:32,248 --> 00:23:33,832
The whole thing's unimportant.
Come on.

430
00:23:33,917 --> 00:23:37,045
- Unimportant? Oh, here, you try it.
- No, nobody wants to change.

431
00:23:37,129 --> 00:23:38,880
You're doing a beautiful job.
Sit down.

432
00:23:38,964 --> 00:23:41,800
Yeah, you're doing great.
Just great, fella.

433
00:23:41,885 --> 00:23:43,761
You stay in there and pitch. You know?

434
00:23:44,722 --> 00:23:46,930
All right. Let's hear from somebody.

435
00:23:48,433 --> 00:23:52,520
Well, if you want me to tell you how I
feel about it, it's all right with me.

436
00:23:52,606 --> 00:23:54,733
Boy, I don't care what you do.

437
00:23:54,816 --> 00:23:57,693
All right, I don't have anything brilliant.

438
00:23:57,778 --> 00:23:59,905
I only know as much as you do.

439
00:23:59,989 --> 00:24:03,742
According to the testimony,
the boy looks guilty. Maybe he is.

440
00:24:03,826 --> 00:24:07,998
I sat there in court for six days
listening while the evidence built up.

441
00:24:08,624 --> 00:24:10,334
Everybody sounded so positive, you know?

442
00:24:10,417 --> 00:24:12,878
I-I began to get a peculiar feeling
about this trial.

443
00:24:12,962 --> 00:24:15,047
I mean, nothing is that positive.

444
00:24:15,132 --> 00:24:17,258
There are a lot of questions
I'd have liked to ask.

445
00:24:17,343 --> 00:24:20,053
I don't know. Maybe they wouldn't
have meant anything, but...

446
00:24:20,138 --> 00:24:22,098
I began to get the feeling
that the defense counsel...

447
00:24:22,182 --> 00:24:24,683
wasn't conducting a thorough-enough
cross-examination.

448
00:24:24,768 --> 00:24:28,146
I mean, he - he let too many things go by,
little things that...

449
00:24:28,231 --> 00:24:30,982
What little things? Listen,
when these fellas don't ask questions...

450
00:24:31,068 --> 00:24:33,568
it's because they know the answers already
and they figure they'll be hurt.

451
00:24:33,654 --> 00:24:37,573
Maybe it's also possible for a lawyer
to be just plain stupid, isn't it?

452
00:24:37,659 --> 00:24:38,951
I mean it's possible.

453
00:24:39,035 --> 00:24:40,702
You sound like you met
my brother-in-law once.

454
00:24:43,791 --> 00:24:46,501
I - I kept putting myself
in the kid's place.

455
00:24:48,337 --> 00:24:50,463
I'd have asked for another lawyer, I think.

456
00:24:50,550 --> 00:24:53,092
I mean, if I was on trial for my life...

457
00:24:53,176 --> 00:24:57,973
I'd want my lawyer to tear the prosecution
witnesses to shreds, or at least try to.

458
00:24:58,057 --> 00:25:02,018
Look, there was one alleged eyewitness
to this killing.

459
00:25:02,563 --> 00:25:05,941
Someone else claims he heard the killing,
saw the boy run out afterwards.

460
00:25:06,024 --> 00:25:08,152
And there was a lot
of circumstantial evidence.

461
00:25:08,236 --> 00:25:11,739
But actually, those two witnesses
were the entire case for the prosecution.

462
00:25:11,824 --> 00:25:13,616
Supposing they're wrong.

463
00:25:13,701 --> 00:25:15,493
What do you mean
supposing they're wrong?

464
00:25:15,578 --> 00:25:17,455
What's the point
of having witnesses at all?

465
00:25:17,539 --> 00:25:20,166
- Could they be wrong?
- What are you trying to say?

466
00:25:20,251 --> 00:25:21,792
Those people sat on the stand under oath.

467
00:25:21,878 --> 00:25:23,419
They're only people.
People make mistakes.

468
00:25:23,504 --> 00:25:25,213
Could they be wrong?

469
00:25:26,007 --> 00:25:28,925
- Well, no, I don't think so.
- Do you know so?

470
00:25:29,010 --> 00:25:30,845
Oh, come on.
Nobody can know a thing like that.

471
00:25:30,929 --> 00:25:32,638
This isn't an exact science.

472
00:25:32,723 --> 00:25:34,057
That's right. It isn't.

473
00:25:39,231 --> 00:25:41,983
Okay, let - Let's get to the point.

474
00:25:42,067 --> 00:25:44,653
What about the switch knife
they found in the old man's chest?

475
00:25:44,738 --> 00:25:47,157
Uh, wait-wait a minute.
There's some people who haven't talked yet.

476
00:25:47,240 --> 00:25:49,242
- Shouldn't we go in order?
- They'll get a chance to talk.

477
00:25:49,326 --> 00:25:51,661
Be quiet a second, will you?

478
00:25:51,746 --> 00:25:53,038
What about it, this...

479
00:25:53,121 --> 00:25:56,584
the knife this fine upright boy
admitted buying the night of the killing?

480
00:25:56,667 --> 00:25:58,002
Let's talk about it.

481
00:25:58,086 --> 00:26:00,337
All right, let's talk about it.
Let's get it in here and look at it.

482
00:26:00,423 --> 00:26:02,174
I'd like to see it again.
Mr. Foreman?

483
00:26:02,258 --> 00:26:05,344
- We all saw what it looks like.
- Why do we have to see it again?

484
00:26:05,428 --> 00:26:07,388
The gentleman has a right
to see exhibits in evidence.

485
00:26:09,599 --> 00:26:11,059
Say, could you bring us the knife?

486
00:26:11,143 --> 00:26:12,937
- Knife?
- Yeah. Thank you.

487
00:26:14,606 --> 00:26:17,858
The knife and the way it was bought
is pretty strong evidence, don't you think?

488
00:26:17,943 --> 00:26:19,610
- I do.
- Good.

489
00:26:19,695 --> 00:26:22,197
Now, suppose we take these facts
one at a time.

490
00:26:22,281 --> 00:26:25,535
One. The boy admitted going out of the house
at 8:00 on the night of the murder...

491
00:26:25,618 --> 00:26:27,537
after being slapped several times
by his father.

492
00:26:27,621 --> 00:26:30,373
No, no. No, he didn't say "slapped."
He said "punched."

493
00:26:30,458 --> 00:26:32,875
There's a difference
between a slap and a punch.

494
00:26:32,962 --> 00:26:35,546
After being hit several times
by his father.

495
00:26:35,630 --> 00:26:37,882
Two. He went directly
to a neighborhood junk shop...

496
00:26:37,967 --> 00:26:40,093
- where he bought one of those -
- Switch knives.

497
00:26:40,177 --> 00:26:42,179
Switchblade knives.

498
00:26:42,264 --> 00:26:44,056
This wasn't what you'd call
an ordinary knife.

499
00:26:44,140 --> 00:26:46,643
It had a very unusual carved handle
and blade.

500
00:26:46,727 --> 00:26:48,228
The storekeeper who sold it to him...

501
00:26:48,312 --> 00:26:51,440
said it was the only one of its kind
he had ever had in stock.

502
00:26:51,525 --> 00:26:55,278
Three. He met some friends of his
in front of a tavern about 8:45.

503
00:26:55,362 --> 00:26:56,862
Am I right so far?

504
00:26:56,948 --> 00:26:59,074
- Yes, you are.
- You bet he is.

505
00:26:59,158 --> 00:27:02,328
He talked with his friends for about
an hour, leaving them at 9:45.

506
00:27:02,412 --> 00:27:05,372
During this time,
they saw the switch knife.

507
00:27:05,457 --> 00:27:07,250
Four.

508
00:27:07,334 --> 00:27:09,752
They identified the death weapon
in court...

509
00:27:09,838 --> 00:27:12,340
as that very same knife.

510
00:27:12,424 --> 00:27:15,218
Five. Ηe arrived home at about 10:00.

511
00:27:15,303 --> 00:27:17,637
Now this is where the stories
offered by the State and the boy...

512
00:27:17,722 --> 00:27:19,640
begin to diverge slightly.

513
00:27:19,725 --> 00:27:22,310
He claims that he went to a movie
at about 11:30...

514
00:27:22,394 --> 00:27:26,439
returning home at 3:10 to find his
father dead and himself arrested.

515
00:27:26,524 --> 00:27:28,567
He also claims that
the two detectives who arrested him...

516
00:27:28,651 --> 00:27:30,944
threw him down a half a flight of stairs.

517
00:27:31,030 --> 00:27:32,864
Now, what happened to the switch knife?

518
00:27:32,948 --> 00:27:35,575
He claims that it fell through a hole
in his pocket on the way to the movies...

519
00:27:35,659 --> 00:27:40,331
sometime between 11:30 and 3:10
and that he never saw it again.

520
00:27:40,414 --> 00:27:42,374
Now there's a tale, gentlemen.

521
00:27:42,459 --> 00:27:45,962
I think it's quite clear that the boy
never went to the movies that night.

522
00:27:46,047 --> 00:27:48,006
No one in the house
saw him go out at 11:30.

523
00:27:48,090 --> 00:27:49,592
No one at the theater identified him.

524
00:27:49,675 --> 00:27:51,803
He couldn't even remember
the names of the pictures he saw.

525
00:27:54,849 --> 00:27:56,559
- What actually happened is this.
- Thank you.

526
00:27:56,643 --> 00:27:59,854
The boy stayed home,
had another fight with his father...

527
00:27:59,937 --> 00:28:03,650
stabbed him to death and left the
house at 10 minutes after 12:00.

528
00:28:03,734 --> 00:28:06,486
He even remembered to wipe the knife
clean of fingerprints.

529
00:28:06,571 --> 00:28:09,198
Now are you trying to tell me
that this knife...

530
00:28:09,282 --> 00:28:11,200
really fell through a hole
in the boy's pocket...

531
00:28:11,284 --> 00:28:13,662
someone picked it up off the street,
went to the boy's house...

532
00:28:13,745 --> 00:28:16,415
and stabbed his father with it
just to test its sharpness?

533
00:28:16,499 --> 00:28:18,501
No. I'm just saying it's possible
the boy lost his knife...

534
00:28:18,584 --> 00:28:20,796
and that somebody else stabbed his father
with a similar knife.

535
00:28:20,879 --> 00:28:22,089
It's just possible.

536
00:28:22,172 --> 00:28:23,756
Take a look at this knife.

537
00:28:25,677 --> 00:28:27,887
It's a very unusual knife.

538
00:28:27,971 --> 00:28:29,514
I've never seen one like it.

539
00:28:29,598 --> 00:28:32,393
Neither had the storekeeper
who sold it to the boy.

540
00:28:32,476 --> 00:28:35,436
Aren't you asking us to accept
a pretty incredible coincidence?

541
00:28:35,522 --> 00:28:37,856
I'm just saying a coincidence is possible.

542
00:28:37,941 --> 00:28:39,441
And I say it's not possible.

543
00:28:46,076 --> 00:28:47,785
Where did that come from?

544
00:28:47,869 --> 00:28:49,246
- Where'd you get that?
- It's the same knife.

545
00:28:49,330 --> 00:28:50,830
What do you think you're doing?

546
00:28:50,915 --> 00:28:52,541
Where did you get it?

547
00:28:52,625 --> 00:28:54,877
I went out walking
for a couple of hours last night.

548
00:28:54,961 --> 00:28:56,963
I walked through the boy's neighborhood.

549
00:28:57,046 --> 00:29:00,049
I bought that at a little pawnshop
just two blocks from the boy's house.

550
00:29:00,135 --> 00:29:01,592
It cost six dollars.

551
00:29:01,678 --> 00:29:04,804
It's against the law
to buy or sell switchblade knives.

552
00:29:04,890 --> 00:29:07,142
That's right. I broke the law.

553
00:29:07,225 --> 00:29:11,228
Listen, you pulled a real bright trick.
Now, supposing you tell me what it proves.

554
00:29:11,314 --> 00:29:13,399
Maybe there are 10 knives like that.
So what?

555
00:29:13,482 --> 00:29:16,277
- Maybe there are.
- Well, what does it mean?

556
00:29:16,361 --> 00:29:19,655
You found another knife like it.
What's that, the discovery of the age or something?

557
00:29:19,741 --> 00:29:22,075
You mean you're asking us to believe
that somebody else did the stabbing...

558
00:29:22,161 --> 00:29:23,953
with exactly the same kind of knife?

559
00:29:24,036 --> 00:29:25,288
The odds are a million-to-one.

560
00:29:25,372 --> 00:29:28,081
- It's possible.
- But not very probable.

561
00:29:29,293 --> 00:29:31,294
Okay, fellas, let's take our seats.

562
00:29:31,380 --> 00:29:33,005
There's no point in standing around
all over the place.

563
00:29:35,050 --> 00:29:38,470
You know, it's interesting that he'd find a
knife exactly like the one the boy bought.

564
00:29:38,554 --> 00:29:41,306
What's interesting about it?
"Interesting."

565
00:29:41,390 --> 00:29:43,267
Well, I don't know.
I just thought it was interesting.

566
00:29:43,351 --> 00:29:45,145
There are still 11 of us here
who think he's guilty.

567
00:29:45,228 --> 00:29:47,522
- Right.
- What do you think you're gonna accomplish?

568
00:29:47,606 --> 00:29:49,440
You're not gonna change anybody's mind.

569
00:29:49,526 --> 00:29:51,903
So if you wanna be stubborn
and hang this jury, go ahead.

570
00:29:51,987 --> 00:29:55,031
The kid will be tried again
and found guilty sure as he's born.

571
00:29:56,575 --> 00:29:58,452
That's probably right.

572
00:29:58,535 --> 00:30:01,747
So what are you gonna do?
You know, we could be here all night.

573
00:30:01,831 --> 00:30:05,083
It's only one night. A boy may die.

574
00:30:05,169 --> 00:30:07,712
Well, why don't we just
set up house here, huh?

575
00:30:07,797 --> 00:30:10,256
Someone send for Potsy the policeman
and get a pinochle deck...

576
00:30:10,342 --> 00:30:12,843
and, uh, we'll just
sweat the whole thing out right here.

577
00:30:14,346 --> 00:30:17,390
- I don't think he ought to joke about it.
- What do you want me to do about it?

578
00:30:17,474 --> 00:30:21,144
Oh, listen! I don't see what all this stuff
about the knife's got to do with anything.

579
00:30:21,230 --> 00:30:24,149
Somebody saw the kid stab his father.
What more do we need?

580
00:30:24,233 --> 00:30:27,027
You guys can talk the ears right off my head.
You know what I mean?

581
00:30:27,110 --> 00:30:29,823
I got three garages of mine goin' to pot
while you're talking.

582
00:30:29,906 --> 00:30:31,573
So let's get done and get outta here.

583
00:30:31,659 --> 00:30:35,078
The knife was very important to the
district attorney. He spent a whole day...

584
00:30:35,162 --> 00:30:37,622
He's a 15th assistant or something.
What does he know about it?

585
00:30:37,707 --> 00:30:39,166
Hey, let's hold it down.

586
00:30:39,250 --> 00:30:41,585
These side arguments
are only slowing us up.

587
00:30:44,464 --> 00:30:45,841
Well, what about it?

588
00:30:45,925 --> 00:30:47,426
You're the only one.

589
00:30:55,353 --> 00:30:57,396
I have a proposition
to make to all of you.

590
00:30:58,481 --> 00:31:00,233
I'm gonna call for another vote.

591
00:31:01,693 --> 00:31:06,907
I want you 11 men to vote
by secret written ballot.

592
00:31:06,991 --> 00:31:09,035
I'll abstain.

593
00:31:09,119 --> 00:31:11,913
If there are 11 votes for guilty,
I won't stand alone.

594
00:31:11,998 --> 00:31:15,792
We'll take in a guilty verdict
to the judge right now.

595
00:31:17,253 --> 00:31:20,965
But if anyone votes not guilty,
we stay here and talk it out.

596
00:31:24,305 --> 00:31:27,223
Well, that's it.
If you want to try it, I'm ready.

597
00:31:27,307 --> 00:31:28,766
All right. Let's do it the hard way.

598
00:31:28,851 --> 00:31:30,769
Okay, that sounds fair.
Everyone agreed?

599
00:31:30,853 --> 00:31:32,937
- Anyone doesn't agree?
- Fine, fine. Let's go.

600
00:31:33,023 --> 00:31:34,064
Here, pass these along.

601
00:31:34,149 --> 00:31:35,900
Is that the right time?

602
00:32:07,979 --> 00:32:33,801
"Guilty."

603
00:32:37,890 --> 00:32:40,517
"Not guilty."

604
00:32:40,601 --> 00:32:42,018
"Guilty."

605
00:32:42,104 --> 00:32:43,771
Boy, how do you like that?

606
00:32:43,854 --> 00:32:46,316
Oh, and another chap flaps his wings.

607
00:32:46,400 --> 00:32:49,152
All right, who was it?
Come on. I want to know.

608
00:32:49,237 --> 00:32:51,487
Excuse me. This was a secret ballot.

609
00:32:51,573 --> 00:32:53,116
We all agreed on that, no?

610
00:32:53,200 --> 00:32:55,326
If the gentleman wanted
to remain secret...

611
00:32:55,411 --> 00:32:57,286
Secret? What do you mean secret?

612
00:32:57,371 --> 00:33:00,581
There are no secrets in a jury room.
I know who it was.

613
00:33:01,334 --> 00:33:03,253
Brother, you really are something.

614
00:33:03,337 --> 00:33:05,338
You sit here, vote guilty
like the rest of us...

615
00:33:05,423 --> 00:33:08,717
and then some golden-voiced preacher
starts tearin' your poor heart out...

616
00:33:08,802 --> 00:33:12,096
about some underprivileged kid
just couldn't help becomin' a murderer...

617
00:33:12,180 --> 00:33:13,682
and you change your vote.

618
00:33:13,765 --> 00:33:15,891
If that isn't the most sick...

619
00:33:15,977 --> 00:33:19,647
Why don't you drop a quarter
in his collection box?

620
00:33:19,732 --> 00:33:21,691
Oh, now just wait a minute.

621
00:33:21,774 --> 00:33:23,359
Listen, you can't talk to me like that.

622
00:33:23,444 --> 00:33:25,279
- No. Who do you think you are?
- Calm down. Calm down.

623
00:33:25,362 --> 00:33:27,698
No. Who does he think he is?
Did you hear him?

624
00:33:27,782 --> 00:33:31,243
- It doesn't matter. He's very excitable. Sit down.
- Excitable? You bet I'm excitable!

625
00:33:31,328 --> 00:33:34,164
We're trying to put a guilty man
in the chair where he belongs!

626
00:33:34,248 --> 00:33:36,916
Someone starts telling us fairy tales,
and we're listenin'!

627
00:33:37,002 --> 00:33:38,752
Hey, uh, come on, huh?

628
00:33:38,837 --> 00:33:40,755
What made you change your vote?

629
00:33:40,839 --> 00:33:42,465
He didn't change his vote.

630
00:33:42,550 --> 00:33:43,716
I did.

631
00:33:43,801 --> 00:33:45,761
- Oh, fine.
- I knew it.

632
00:33:45,846 --> 00:33:47,805
Would you like me to tell you why?

633
00:33:47,889 --> 00:33:49,765
No, I wouldn't like you to tell me why.

634
00:33:49,850 --> 00:33:52,393
I'd like to make it clear anyway,
if you don't mind.

635
00:33:52,478 --> 00:33:53,979
Do we have to listen to this?

636
00:33:54,063 --> 00:33:55,814
The man wants to talk.

637
00:33:55,899 --> 00:33:57,483
Thank you.

638
00:33:57,568 --> 00:34:00,903
This gentleman has been
standing alone against us.

639
00:34:00,988 --> 00:34:03,239
Now, he doesn't say
the boy is not guilty.

640
00:34:03,324 --> 00:34:05,283
He just isn't sure.

641
00:34:05,367 --> 00:34:08,204
Well, it's not easy to stand alone
against the ridicule of others.

642
00:34:08,288 --> 00:34:11,415
So he gambled for support,
and I gave it to him.

643
00:34:11,501 --> 00:34:13,210
I respect his motives.

644
00:34:13,294 --> 00:34:17,840
The boy on trial is probably guilty,
but, uh, I want to hear more.

645
00:34:17,925 --> 00:34:19,717
Right now, the vote is 10 to two.

646
00:34:19,802 --> 00:34:22,054
I'm talking here!
You have no right to leave this room!

647
00:34:22,137 --> 00:34:24,014
He can't hear you. He never will.

648
00:34:24,099 --> 00:34:25,682
Let's sit down.

649
00:34:29,854 --> 00:34:32,066
Shall we continue?

650
00:34:32,149 --> 00:34:34,359
Well, I - I think we ought
to take a break.

651
00:34:34,444 --> 00:34:38,572
You know, one man's inside,
and I think we ought to wait for him.

652
00:34:38,658 --> 00:34:41,618
Okay.

653
00:34:41,702 --> 00:34:43,453
Looks like we're really
hung up here, huh?

654
00:34:44,832 --> 00:34:47,166
And that thing with the old man,
that was pretty unexpected.

655
00:34:49,254 --> 00:34:51,713
I wish I could figure out some way
we could break it up.

656
00:34:54,843 --> 00:34:58,304
You know, in advertising -
I told you I worked in an agency.

657
00:34:58,389 --> 00:34:59,389
Mm-hmm.

658
00:34:59,473 --> 00:35:01,474
Well, there's some pretty strange people
working there.

659
00:35:01,560 --> 00:35:03,644
Well, they're not strange really, I guess.

660
00:35:03,728 --> 00:35:06,355
It's just that they have peculiar ways
of expressing themselves.

661
00:35:06,439 --> 00:35:07,690
You know what I mean.

662
00:35:07,775 --> 00:35:09,985
Of course, I suppose it's the same
in your business too, huh?

663
00:35:10,736 --> 00:35:12,237
What do you do?

664
00:35:12,322 --> 00:35:14,489
- I'm a watchmaker.
- Oh, really?

665
00:35:14,575 --> 00:35:17,786
Well, I imagine the finest watchmakers
in the world come from Europe, huh?

666
00:35:17,871 --> 00:35:20,873
Anyway, as I was telling you, in an
agency, when we reach a point like this...

667
00:35:20,956 --> 00:35:24,460
I'm telling him about, in an ad agency, when
a point like this is reached in a meeting...

668
00:35:24,544 --> 00:35:27,172
there's always some character
ready with an idea, see.

669
00:35:27,256 --> 00:35:29,215
And it kills me.

670
00:35:29,300 --> 00:35:30,800
It's the weirdest thing in the world...

671
00:35:30,886 --> 00:35:34,220
the way they sometimes precede their idea
with a little phrase, see, like...

672
00:35:34,307 --> 00:35:37,225
Some account exec will get up,
and he'll say, uh...

673
00:35:37,310 --> 00:35:39,144
"Okay, here's an idea.

674
00:35:39,228 --> 00:35:42,857
Let's, uh, run it up the flagpole
and see if anyone salutes it."

675
00:35:42,940 --> 00:35:46,068
I mean, it's idiotic, but it's funny, huh?

676
00:35:46,153 --> 00:35:50,657
I, uh
- I got a little excited back there. I...

677
00:35:51,660 --> 00:35:53,411
didn't mean to get nasty.

678
00:35:54,287 --> 00:35:58,083
I'm glad you're not one of those
lets these emotional appeals influence him.

679
00:35:59,252 --> 00:36:01,503
Uh...

680
00:36:14,770 --> 00:36:17,481
I don't know what's the matter with that fan.
Can't seem to get it to start.

681
00:36:18,857 --> 00:36:21,402
♪ Be, be, be ♪

682
00:36:21,486 --> 00:36:23,571
♪ Ba, ba, ba, ba, bum ♪♪

683
00:36:24,156 --> 00:36:26,074
Eh!

684
00:36:27,201 --> 00:36:29,411
Hey, you a salesman?

685
00:36:29,496 --> 00:36:30,996
I'm an architect.

686
00:36:31,832 --> 00:36:33,166
Hmm.

687
00:36:33,250 --> 00:36:35,502
You know what the soft sell is?

688
00:36:38,423 --> 00:36:40,341
Boy, you got it. Believe me.

689
00:36:42,011 --> 00:36:43,719
I got a different technique.

690
00:36:44,514 --> 00:36:46,306
Laughs, drinks, jokes.

691
00:36:46,391 --> 00:36:48,643
Tricks. You know?

692
00:36:49,478 --> 00:36:50,687
Yeah.

693
00:36:52,147 --> 00:36:54,358
"Hit 'em where they live."
That's my motto.

694
00:36:55,776 --> 00:36:58,529
I made 27 grand last year
sellin' marmalade.

695
00:36:59,364 --> 00:37:01,867
That's not bad. I mean,
you know, considering marmalade.

696
00:37:05,080 --> 00:37:06,872
Hey, what are you
gettin' outta this - kicks?

697
00:37:09,042 --> 00:37:11,628
Or did somebody bump you on the head
one time and you haven't gotten over it?

698
00:37:11,713 --> 00:37:13,422
Maybe.

699
00:37:14,424 --> 00:37:16,967
You know, you do-gooders are all alike.

700
00:37:17,051 --> 00:37:19,721
You're always blowing your stacks
over some guy that fanned.

701
00:37:22,809 --> 00:37:24,643
But what are you wasting our time for?

702
00:37:25,395 --> 00:37:29,440
Why don't you donate five dollars to the
cause, and maybe it'll make you feel better.

703
00:37:32,737 --> 00:37:34,989
This kid is guilty, pal.

704
00:37:35,072 --> 00:37:37,491
It's as plain as the nose on your face.

705
00:37:37,575 --> 00:37:39,827
So why don't we stop
wasting our time here?

706
00:37:39,912 --> 00:37:42,831
We're gonna all get sore throats
if we keep it up, you know?

707
00:37:42,916 --> 00:37:45,208
What difference does it make
if you get it here or at the ball game?

708
00:37:46,253 --> 00:37:49,172
Oh, no difference, pal.

709
00:37:49,256 --> 00:37:51,050
No difference at all.

710
00:38:02,982 --> 00:38:04,857
Nice bunch of guys, huh?

711
00:38:04,941 --> 00:38:07,234
Oh, they're about the same
as anyone else.

712
00:38:07,319 --> 00:38:10,112
Phew! Boy, what a murderous day.

713
00:38:11,116 --> 00:38:13,158
You think we'll be much longer?

714
00:38:13,243 --> 00:38:14,868
I don't know.

715
00:38:14,953 --> 00:38:16,871
Aw, he's guilty for sure.

716
00:38:16,954 --> 00:38:18,499
Not a doubt in the whole world.

717
00:38:18,582 --> 00:38:21,127
We should -
Should've been done already.

718
00:38:23,380 --> 00:38:24,630
Oh, I don't mind, you know.

719
00:38:24,714 --> 00:38:27,133
Hmm. Beats workin'.

720
00:38:30,806 --> 00:38:31,972
Uh...

721
00:38:34,351 --> 00:38:36,435
You think he's not guilty, huh?

722
00:38:36,521 --> 00:38:38,356
I don't know. It's possible.

723
00:38:39,107 --> 00:38:42,902
Well, I don't know you, but I'm bettin'
you never been wronger in your life.

724
00:38:42,986 --> 00:38:45,405
You're wasting your time.
You ought to wrap it up.

725
00:38:45,489 --> 00:38:47,658
Supposing you were the one
who was on trial.

726
00:38:48,493 --> 00:38:50,370
Well, I'm not used to supposing.

727
00:38:50,453 --> 00:38:54,958
I'm just a workingman.
My boss does the supposing. But...

728
00:38:55,042 --> 00:38:56,544
Well, I'll try one.

729
00:38:57,753 --> 00:39:03,426
Supposing you talk us all out of this, and,
uh, the kid really did knife his father. Huh?

730
00:39:12,354 --> 00:39:13,646
Are you ready?

731
00:39:13,730 --> 00:39:14,940
Hup.

732
00:39:15,023 --> 00:39:15,940
That one.

733
00:39:16,025 --> 00:39:17,693
Sorry, blue eyes.

734
00:39:18,611 --> 00:39:22,030
- Well, where else -
- Okay, fellas, let's take our seats.

735
00:39:22,116 --> 00:39:24,033
Looks like we'll be here
for dinner, huh?

736
00:39:24,117 --> 00:39:26,494
Okay, now let's -
Let's get down to business.

737
00:39:26,580 --> 00:39:27,955
Now, who wants to start it off?

738
00:39:28,038 --> 00:39:29,458
- I would.
- Okay, go.

739
00:39:29,541 --> 00:39:31,625
You down there.

740
00:39:31,710 --> 00:39:35,589
The old man who lived downstairs says he
heard the kid yell out, "I'm gonna kill ya."

741
00:39:35,672 --> 00:39:38,300
A second later,
he heard the body hit the floor.

742
00:39:38,385 --> 00:39:42,263
Now, he ran to the door and he saw the kid
running down the stairs and out of the house.

743
00:39:42,348 --> 00:39:43,723
What does that mean to you?

744
00:39:43,807 --> 00:39:47,186
I was wondering how clearly the old man could
have heard the boy's voice through the ceiling.

745
00:39:47,270 --> 00:39:49,314
He didn't hear it through the ceiling.
The window was open.

746
00:39:49,397 --> 00:39:51,232
So was the one upstairs.
It was a hot night, remember?

747
00:39:51,317 --> 00:39:52,649
Well, it was another apartment.

748
00:39:52,736 --> 00:39:55,320
It's not that easy to identify a voice,
particularly a shouting voice.

749
00:39:55,405 --> 00:39:56,988
- He identified it in court.
- That's right.

750
00:39:57,073 --> 00:39:58,532
And don't forget the lady
across the street.

751
00:39:58,617 --> 00:40:01,411
She looked right in the open window
and saw the boy stab his father.

752
00:40:01,496 --> 00:40:03,956
- Now, I mean, isn't that enough for you?
- No, it isn't.

753
00:40:04,040 --> 00:40:06,000
Boy, how do you like this guy, huh?

754
00:40:06,083 --> 00:40:07,918
It's like talking into a dead phone.

755
00:40:08,003 --> 00:40:11,173
She said she saw the killing through the
windows of a moving elevated train.

756
00:40:11,257 --> 00:40:14,761
There were six cars on the train.
She saw the killing through the last two cars.

757
00:40:14,844 --> 00:40:16,678
She remembered
the most insignificant details.

758
00:40:16,763 --> 00:40:18,806
I don't see how you can argue with that.

759
00:40:18,891 --> 00:40:23,437
Has anybody here any idea
how long it would take an el...

760
00:40:32,115 --> 00:40:33,699
Hey!

761
00:40:33,784 --> 00:40:35,285
This isn't a game.

762
00:40:39,581 --> 00:40:41,833
- Did you see him?
- Hey.

763
00:40:41,918 --> 00:40:43,669
- The nerve.
- All right, listen...

764
00:40:43,753 --> 00:40:47,006
- The absolute nerve.
- Forget it. It's not important.

765
00:40:47,091 --> 00:40:49,050
- "This isn't a game"?
- Calm down.

766
00:40:49,134 --> 00:40:52,470
- Who does he think he is?
- I'm telling you, forget it now.

767
00:40:52,557 --> 00:40:55,891
Has anybody any idea how long
it takes an elevated train...

768
00:40:55,977 --> 00:40:57,812
going at medium speed
to pass a given point?

769
00:40:57,895 --> 00:40:59,772
- What has that to do with anything?
- How long? Take a guess.

770
00:40:59,855 --> 00:41:02,525
- I wouldn't have the slightest idea.
- What do you think?

771
00:41:02,609 --> 00:41:04,485
I don't know. Maybe 10, 12 seconds?

772
00:41:05,487 --> 00:41:07,155
I think that's a pretty good guess.
Anyone else?

773
00:41:07,239 --> 00:41:10,033
- That sounds right to me.
- Come on. What's the guessing game for?

774
00:41:10,118 --> 00:41:11,952
- What do you say?
- Ten seconds is about right.

775
00:41:12,036 --> 00:41:13,955
All right. Say 10 seconds.
What are you getting at?

776
00:41:14,038 --> 00:41:19,086
This. It takes a six-car el train
10 seconds to pass a given point.

777
00:41:19,169 --> 00:41:23,424
Now let's say the given point is the open window
of the room where the killing took place.

778
00:41:23,508 --> 00:41:26,803
You can reach out of that window
and almost touch the el tracks, right?

779
00:41:26,887 --> 00:41:28,388
Now let me ask you this.

780
00:41:28,473 --> 00:41:30,725
Has anyone here
ever lived near the el tracks?

781
00:41:30,809 --> 00:41:34,437
Well, uh, I just finished painting an
apartment that overlooked an el line.

782
00:41:34,522 --> 00:41:36,188
- I was there for three days.
- What was it like?

783
00:41:36,273 --> 00:41:37,441
- What do you mean?
- Noisy?

784
00:41:37,524 --> 00:41:40,069
Oh, brother. Don't matter though.
We were all punchy.

785
00:41:40,153 --> 00:41:42,738
I lived in a second-floor apartment
near the el line once.

786
00:41:42,823 --> 00:41:45,867
When the window was open and the train
goes by, the noise is almost unbearable.

787
00:41:45,994 --> 00:41:48,786
- You can hardly hear yourself think.
- All right, you can't hear yourself think.

788
00:41:48,872 --> 00:41:51,290
- Will you get to the point?
- I will. Now just a minute.

789
00:41:51,375 --> 00:41:55,003
Let's take two pieces of testimony
and try to put them together.

790
00:41:55,086 --> 00:41:59,174
First. The old man in the
apartment downstairs.

791
00:41:59,259 --> 00:42:01,844
He says he heard the boy say
"I'm gonna kill you"...

792
00:42:01,928 --> 00:42:04,681
and a split second later
heard a body hit the floor.

793
00:42:04,765 --> 00:42:06,350
- One second later, right?
- That's right.

794
00:42:06,433 --> 00:42:12,440
Second. The woman across the street swore
positively she looked out of the window...

795
00:42:12,524 --> 00:42:15,861
and saw the killing through the last two
cars of the passing elevated train, right?

796
00:42:15,945 --> 00:42:18,280
- The last two cars.
- What are you giving us here?

797
00:42:18,365 --> 00:42:19,697
Now, just a minute.

798
00:42:19,784 --> 00:42:24,204
We've agreed that it takes 10 seconds
for a train to pass a given point.

799
00:42:25,040 --> 00:42:28,376
Since the woman saw the killing
through the last two cars...

800
00:42:28,460 --> 00:42:33,423
we can assume that the body
hit the floor just as the train went by.

801
00:42:33,508 --> 00:42:37,970
Therefore, the train had been roaring
by the old man's window...

802
00:42:38,054 --> 00:42:41,557
a full 10 seconds
before the body hit the floor.

803
00:42:41,642 --> 00:42:43,852
The old man,
according to his own testimony...

804
00:42:43,936 --> 00:42:46,855
"I'm gonna kill you," body hitting
the floor a split second later...

805
00:42:46,940 --> 00:42:49,400
would have had to hear the boy
make this statement...

806
00:42:49,485 --> 00:42:51,361
with the el roaring past his nose.

807
00:42:51,444 --> 00:42:52,987
It's not possible he could've heard it.

808
00:42:53,072 --> 00:42:55,241
- That's idiotic. Of course he heard it.
- Do you think he could've heard it?

809
00:42:55,325 --> 00:42:57,702
He said he yelled at the top of his voice.
That's good enough for me.

810
00:42:57,786 --> 00:43:00,038
Even if he heard something, he still
couldn't have identified the voice.

811
00:43:00,123 --> 00:43:01,248
With the el roaring by?

812
00:43:01,331 --> 00:43:03,709
You're talking about a matter of seconds!
Nobody can be that accurate.

813
00:43:03,793 --> 00:43:08,423
I think testimony that could put a boy into
the electric chair should be that accurate.

814
00:43:10,635 --> 00:43:12,553
You know something?
I don't think he could've heard it.

815
00:43:12,636 --> 00:43:14,972
Maybe he didn't hear it.
I mean, with all that el noise.

816
00:43:15,056 --> 00:43:16,933
Oh, what are you people talking about?

817
00:43:17,016 --> 00:43:19,060
Well, it stands to reason
he couldn't have heard it.

818
00:43:19,145 --> 00:43:21,062
Why should he lie?
What's he got to gain?

819
00:43:21,147 --> 00:43:23,357
Attention maybe.

820
00:43:23,441 --> 00:43:25,359
You keep coming in
with these bright sayings!

821
00:43:25,444 --> 00:43:28,488
Why don't you send 'em in to a paper?
They pay three dollars apiece.

822
00:43:28,572 --> 00:43:30,782
What are you talking to him
like that for?

823
00:43:31,743 --> 00:43:35,162
Guy talks like that to an old man
really ought to get stepped on, you know?

824
00:43:35,247 --> 00:43:37,081
You ought to have more respect, mister.

825
00:43:38,293 --> 00:43:42,671
If you say stuff like that to him again,
I'm gonna lay you out.

826
00:43:52,643 --> 00:43:55,603
Now you go ahead.
You - You say anything you like.

827
00:43:55,687 --> 00:43:59,733
Why do you think
the old man might lie?

828
00:43:59,817 --> 00:44:03,237
It was just that I looked at him
for a very long time.

829
00:44:03,864 --> 00:44:07,117
The seams of his jacket was split,
under the shoulder.

830
00:44:07,201 --> 00:44:08,786
Or did you notice that?

831
00:44:08,869 --> 00:44:11,371
I mean, to come to court like that.

832
00:44:11,457 --> 00:44:13,124
Why...

833
00:44:14,250 --> 00:44:18,129
He was a very old man
in a torn jacket.

834
00:44:18,214 --> 00:44:21,090
And he walked very slowly
to the stand.

835
00:44:21,843 --> 00:44:25,888
He was dragging his left leg
and trying to hide it...

836
00:44:25,973 --> 00:44:27,642
because he was ashamed.

837
00:44:28,768 --> 00:44:32,188
I think I know this man
better than anyone here.

838
00:44:33,065 --> 00:44:38,487
This is a quiet, frightened,
insignificant old man who...

839
00:44:38,571 --> 00:44:40,949
who has been nothing all his life...

840
00:44:41,032 --> 00:44:43,451
who has never had recognition...

841
00:44:43,536 --> 00:44:45,621
or his name in the newspapers.

842
00:44:46,288 --> 00:44:48,499
Nobody knows him.

843
00:44:48,583 --> 00:44:50,626
Nobody quotes him.

844
00:44:50,710 --> 00:44:54,672
Nobody seeks his advice after 75 years.

845
00:44:55,508 --> 00:44:59,387
Gentlemen, that's a very sad thing -
to be nothing.

846
00:45:00,097 --> 00:45:04,433
A man like this needs to be quoted,
to be listened to.

847
00:45:05,061 --> 00:45:07,021
To be quoted just once.

848
00:45:07,105 --> 00:45:08,982
Very important to him.

849
00:45:09,483 --> 00:45:11,901
It would be so hard for him
to recede into the background...

850
00:45:11,986 --> 00:45:13,695
- Wait a minute.
- When there was a chance...

851
00:45:13,779 --> 00:45:16,657
What are you trying to do - tell us he'd
lie just so he could be important once?

852
00:45:16,741 --> 00:45:19,369
No. He wouldn't really lie.

853
00:45:19,452 --> 00:45:22,914
But perhaps he made himself believe
he heard those words...

854
00:45:22,999 --> 00:45:25,208
and recognized the boy's face.

855
00:45:25,293 --> 00:45:27,586
That's the most fantastic story
I've ever heard.

856
00:45:27,671 --> 00:45:30,716
How can you make up a thing like that?
What do you know about it?

857
00:45:39,768 --> 00:45:41,811
Oh, uh, does anybody
want a cough drop?

858
00:45:41,897 --> 00:45:44,148
- No, thanks.
- I'll take one.

859
00:45:44,231 --> 00:45:47,735
You can say what you like. I still don't
see how anybody can think he's not guilty.

860
00:45:47,819 --> 00:45:50,322
There's something else
I'd like to talk about for a minute.

861
00:45:50,406 --> 00:45:52,033
Thanks.

862
00:45:52,116 --> 00:45:55,410
I think we've proved that the old man couldn't
have heard the boy say "I'm gonna kill you."

863
00:45:55,494 --> 00:45:57,078
- But supposing -
- You didn't prove it at all.

864
00:45:57,165 --> 00:45:59,958
- What are you talking about?
- Supposing he really did hear it.

865
00:46:00,043 --> 00:46:02,462
This phrase, how many times
have all of us used it?

866
00:46:02,545 --> 00:46:04,046
Probably thousands.

867
00:46:04,130 --> 00:46:05,756
"I could kill you for that, darling."

868
00:46:05,841 --> 00:46:07,759
"Junior, you do that once more,
and I'm gonna kill you."

869
00:46:07,843 --> 00:46:09,135
"Get in there, Rocky, and kill him."

870
00:46:09,219 --> 00:46:11,095
We say it every day. That doesn't mean
we're really gonna kill anybody.

871
00:46:11,180 --> 00:46:12,973
Wait a minute.
What are you trying to give us here?

872
00:46:13,058 --> 00:46:16,769
The phrase was "I'm gonna kill you."
The kid yelled it at the top of his lungs.

873
00:46:16,854 --> 00:46:18,188
Don't tell me he didn't mean it.

874
00:46:18,271 --> 00:46:20,565
Anybody says a thing like that
the way he said it, they mean it.

875
00:46:20,650 --> 00:46:22,109
Well, gee, now I don't know.

876
00:46:22,194 --> 00:46:26,907
I remember I was arguing with a guy I work
next to at the bank a couple weeks ago.

877
00:46:26,990 --> 00:46:28,742
He called me an idiot, so I yelled at him.

878
00:46:28,825 --> 00:46:31,788
Now listen! This guy's trying to make you
believe things that aren't so.

879
00:46:31,871 --> 00:46:33,956
The kid said he was gonna kill him,
and he did kill him.

880
00:46:34,041 --> 00:46:37,001
Let me ask you this. Do you really think the
boy would shout out a thing like that...

881
00:46:37,087 --> 00:46:38,878
so the whole neighborhood could hear him?

882
00:46:38,964 --> 00:46:40,797
I don't think so.
He's much too bright for that.

883
00:46:40,882 --> 00:46:45,637
Bright? He's a common ignorant slob.
He don't even speak good English.

884
00:46:45,720 --> 00:46:48,555
"He doesn't even speak good English."

885
00:46:51,019 --> 00:46:54,814
Mr. Foreman, I'd like
to change my vote to not guilty.

886
00:46:54,898 --> 00:46:56,315
You what?

887
00:46:56,401 --> 00:46:58,819
- You heard me.
- Are you sure?

888
00:46:59,736 --> 00:47:01,155
Yeah, I'm sure.

889
00:47:01,239 --> 00:47:03,699
The vote is nine to three,
favor of guilty.

890
00:47:03,784 --> 00:47:06,577
Well, if this isn't the living end. Huh?

891
00:47:10,625 --> 00:47:13,377
What are you basing it on -
the stories this guy made up?

892
00:47:14,005 --> 00:47:16,339
You ought to write for one of those
kooky detective magazines.

893
00:47:16,424 --> 00:47:18,258
You'd make a fortune.

894
00:47:18,343 --> 00:47:21,762
For crying out loud. The kid's own lawyer
knew he didn't stand a chance.

895
00:47:22,263 --> 00:47:23,848
Right from the beginning,
his own lawyer knew it.

896
00:47:23,932 --> 00:47:25,726
You could see it.

897
00:47:25,809 --> 00:47:29,396
Boy, oh, boy. I'm tellin' you,
this guy here is really something.

898
00:47:30,232 --> 00:47:32,025
Look, the kid had a lawyer, didn't he?

899
00:47:32,109 --> 00:47:34,944
He presented his case, not you.
How come you got so much to say?

900
00:47:35,029 --> 00:47:37,865
- Look, lawyers aren't infallible, you know.
- Baltimore, please. Huh?

901
00:47:37,948 --> 00:47:39,658
He was court-appointed.

902
00:47:39,744 --> 00:47:41,578
- What's that supposed to mean?
- It could mean a lot of things.

903
00:47:41,662 --> 00:47:44,914
It could mean he didn't want the case,
or he resented being appointed.

904
00:47:45,000 --> 00:47:46,833
It's the kind of case
that brings him nothing...

905
00:47:46,918 --> 00:47:49,879
no money, no glory,
not even much chance of winning.

906
00:47:49,963 --> 00:47:52,883
That's not a very promising situation
for a young lawyer.

907
00:47:52,967 --> 00:47:55,886
He'd really have to believe in his client
to put up any kind of a good case...

908
00:47:55,970 --> 00:47:57,971
and, as you pointed out a minute ago,
obviously he didn't.

909
00:47:58,057 --> 00:48:00,892
Of course he didn't. Huh.

910
00:48:00,976 --> 00:48:03,269
Who the heck could?

911
00:48:03,354 --> 00:48:06,273
Except maybe
some guy's mother or somebody. I...

912
00:48:06,356 --> 00:48:08,609
Ah, look.
Will you look at the time, huh?

913
00:48:08,694 --> 00:48:11,236
- Come on. For crying out -
- Pardon me.

914
00:48:11,322 --> 00:48:13,656
- I have made some notes here -
- Notes.

915
00:48:13,740 --> 00:48:16,367
And I would like to -
please, to say something.

916
00:48:16,453 --> 00:48:18,705
- Yeah.
- I have been listening very carefully.

917
00:48:18,789 --> 00:48:23,210
And, uh, it seems to me that this man
has some very good points to make.

918
00:48:23,294 --> 00:48:27,924
From what was presented at the trial,
the boy looks guilty on the surface.

919
00:48:28,008 --> 00:48:32,095
- But maybe if we go deeper?
- Oh, come on, will ya?

920
00:48:32,179 --> 00:48:34,473
There is a question I would like to ask.

921
00:48:34,557 --> 00:48:37,851
Let us assume that the boy
really did commit the murder.

922
00:48:37,937 --> 00:48:41,272
Now, this happened
at 10 minutes after 12:00.

923
00:48:41,357 --> 00:48:43,817
Now, how was he caught by the police?

924
00:48:43,901 --> 00:48:48,406
He came back home, uh, at 3:00 or so...

925
00:48:48,490 --> 00:48:52,244
and he was captured by two detectives
in the hallway of his house.

926
00:48:52,327 --> 00:48:56,916
Now, my question is,
if he really had killed his father...

927
00:48:57,000 --> 00:49:00,211
why would he come back home
three hours later?

928
00:49:00,296 --> 00:49:03,173
Wouldn't he be afraid of being caught?

929
00:49:03,258 --> 00:49:05,008
He came home to get his knife.

930
00:49:05,093 --> 00:49:07,637
It's not nice to go around leaving knives
sticking in people's chests.

931
00:49:07,721 --> 00:49:10,473
- Yeah, especially relatives.
- Yeah.

932
00:49:10,559 --> 00:49:12,810
I don't see anything funny about it.

933
00:49:12,894 --> 00:49:16,438
The boy knew the knife could be identified
as the one he had just bought.

934
00:49:16,524 --> 00:49:18,692
He had to get it before the police did.

935
00:49:18,775 --> 00:49:23,238
But if he knew the knife could be identified,
why did he leave it there in the first place?

936
00:49:23,782 --> 00:49:26,659
Well, I think we can assume
the boy ran out in a state of panic...

937
00:49:26,743 --> 00:49:29,121
after having just killed his father.

938
00:49:29,204 --> 00:49:32,167
When he finally calmed down,
he realized he had left his knife there.

939
00:49:32,250 --> 00:49:35,170
Ah. This then depends
on your definition of panic.

940
00:49:35,253 --> 00:49:37,630
He would have had to be
calm enough to see to it...

941
00:49:37,715 --> 00:49:40,301
that there were no fingerprints
left on the knife.

942
00:49:40,384 --> 00:49:44,430
Now, where did this panic start
and where did it end?

943
00:49:44,514 --> 00:49:46,892
Look, you voted guilty.
What side are ya on?

944
00:49:46,975 --> 00:49:50,520
I don't believe I have to be loyal
to one side or the other.

945
00:49:50,605 --> 00:49:52,398
I'm simply asking questions.

946
00:49:52,481 --> 00:49:55,485
Well, this is just off the top of my head,
but, uh...

947
00:49:55,570 --> 00:49:58,071
well, if I were the boy
and I'd done the stabbing and everything...

948
00:49:58,155 --> 00:50:00,283
I'd take a chance
and go back for the knife.

949
00:50:00,366 --> 00:50:02,868
I'll bet he figured that nobody
had seen him running out...

950
00:50:02,953 --> 00:50:05,455
and that the body wouldn't be discovered
till the next day.

951
00:50:05,539 --> 00:50:07,583
Well, after all,
it was the middle of the night.

952
00:50:07,667 --> 00:50:10,169
I'll bet he'd figured nobody
would find the body till the next day.

953
00:50:10,252 --> 00:50:12,254
Pardon. This is my whole point.

954
00:50:12,340 --> 00:50:16,051
The woman across the street testified that
the moment after she saw the killing...

955
00:50:16,135 --> 00:50:18,720
that is, a moment
after the train went by...

956
00:50:18,804 --> 00:50:21,807
she screamed
and then went to telephone the police.

957
00:50:21,892 --> 00:50:25,270
Now, the boy certainly
must have heard the scream...

958
00:50:25,355 --> 00:50:28,858
so he knew
that somebody saw something.

959
00:50:28,942 --> 00:50:31,736
I just don't think
that he would have gone back.

960
00:50:31,820 --> 00:50:34,573
Two things. One, in his state of panic,
he may not have heard the scream.

961
00:50:34,657 --> 00:50:36,324
Perhaps it wasn't very loud.

962
00:50:36,408 --> 00:50:39,787
Two, if he did hear it, he may not
have connected it with his own act.

963
00:50:39,871 --> 00:50:42,916
Remember, he lived in a neighborhood
where screams were fairly commonplace.

964
00:50:43,000 --> 00:50:45,460
- There's your answer.
- Maybe.

965
00:50:45,544 --> 00:50:48,421
Maybe the boy did kill his father,
didn't hear the scream...

966
00:50:48,507 --> 00:50:52,219
did run out in a panic,
did calm down three hours later...

967
00:50:52,302 --> 00:50:54,930
and come back to get the knife,
risking being caught by the police.

968
00:50:55,014 --> 00:50:57,933
Maybe all of those things happened,
but maybe they didn't.

969
00:50:58,018 --> 00:51:00,770
I think there's enough doubt that we can
wonder whether he was there at all...

970
00:51:00,854 --> 00:51:02,522
during the time the killing took place.

971
00:51:02,607 --> 00:51:04,357
What do you mean doubt?
What are you talking about?

972
00:51:04,442 --> 00:51:06,151
Didn't the old man see him
running out of the house?

973
00:51:06,236 --> 00:51:08,028
He's twisting the facts, I'm telling you.

974
00:51:08,113 --> 00:51:11,450
Did or didn't the old man see the kid
running out of the house at 12:10?

975
00:51:11,534 --> 00:51:13,451
Well, did or didn't he?

976
00:51:13,537 --> 00:51:16,747
- He says he did.
- "Says he did"? Boy! How do you like that?

977
00:51:16,832 --> 00:51:19,792
- Now, look, witnesses can make mistakes.
- Sure, when you want them to, they do.

978
00:51:19,877 --> 00:51:22,128
Or when he wants them to, they do.
You know what I mean?

979
00:51:22,213 --> 00:51:24,047
- Keep the yelling down!
- Oh, you keep saying that.

980
00:51:24,132 --> 00:51:25,841
Maybe what we need
is a little yelling in here.

981
00:51:25,926 --> 00:51:27,635
These guys
keep going off every which way.

982
00:51:27,720 --> 00:51:29,637
Did hear the scream.
Didn't hear the scream.

983
00:51:29,722 --> 00:51:32,891
What difference does it make? You people
are talking only about the little details.

984
00:51:32,975 --> 00:51:35,477
You're forgetting the important stuff.
I mean, all of a sudden, everybody here...

985
00:51:35,562 --> 00:51:37,939
- I want to call for another vote.
- I'm talking here!

986
00:51:38,024 --> 00:51:41,694
There's another vote called for.
Now let's take our seats.

987
00:51:45,574 --> 00:51:48,117
I never saw so much time
spent on nothing.

988
00:51:48,201 --> 00:51:49,910
It only takes a second.

989
00:51:50,997 --> 00:51:54,417
Okay. I guess the fastest way
is to find out who's voting not guilty.

990
00:51:54,501 --> 00:51:57,254
Now, all those voting not guilty,
please raise your hands.

991
00:51:58,505 --> 00:52:02,092
Still the same.
One, two, three not guilty. Nine guilty.

992
00:52:02,177 --> 00:52:03,845
So, now where are we?

993
00:52:03,928 --> 00:52:07,349
I'm telling you, we can yackety-yack until
next Tuesday. Where's it all getting us?

994
00:52:07,433 --> 00:52:10,185
Pardon. I vote not guilty.

995
00:52:10,270 --> 00:52:13,271
Oh!

996
00:52:13,357 --> 00:52:16,650
What are ya talking about? I mean,
we're all going crazy in here or something.

997
00:52:16,736 --> 00:52:20,531
The kid is guilty.
Why don't you listen to the facts?

998
00:52:20,615 --> 00:52:22,866
Tell him, will ya?
Now this is getting to be a joke.

999
00:52:22,951 --> 00:52:26,163
The vote is eight to four,
favor of guilty.

1000
00:52:26,246 --> 00:52:29,917
What is this, love your underprivileged
brother week or something?

1001
00:52:30,001 --> 00:52:32,503
I want you to get up and tell me
why you changed your vote.

1002
00:52:32,587 --> 00:52:36,883
- Come on. Give me your reasons.
- I don't have to defend my decision to you.

1003
00:52:36,967 --> 00:52:38,719
There is a reasonable doubt in my mind.

1004
00:52:38,803 --> 00:52:41,805
What reasonable doubt? That's nothing but words.
Here, look at this.

1005
00:52:41,891 --> 00:52:46,812
The kid you just decided isn't guilty
was seen ramming this into his father.

1006
00:52:46,896 --> 00:52:48,897
Now, what about this,
Mr. Reasonable Doubt?

1007
00:52:48,981 --> 00:52:51,650
That's not the knife.
Don't you remember?

1008
00:52:51,735 --> 00:52:53,903
Oh, brilliant.

1009
00:52:53,988 --> 00:52:56,280
I'm telling ya, this is the craziest.

1010
00:52:56,366 --> 00:52:58,534
I mean, what are we supposed to believe?

1011
00:52:58,618 --> 00:53:01,453
I mean, you're sittin' here, you're pulling
stories out of thin air, you know?

1012
00:53:01,538 --> 00:53:05,250
A guy like this, if he's, uh, sitting
ringside at the Dempsey-Firpo fight...

1013
00:53:05,335 --> 00:53:07,795
he'd be trying to tell you that, uh...

1014
00:53:07,878 --> 00:53:10,256
Look. Now, what about the old man?

1015
00:53:10,339 --> 00:53:12,926
Are we supposed to believe that he
didn't get up and run to his door...

1016
00:53:13,009 --> 00:53:16,012
and see the kid tearing down the steps
15 seconds after the killing?

1017
00:53:16,097 --> 00:53:18,557
He's just saying so to be important, right?

1018
00:53:18,641 --> 00:53:21,436
- I mean, what's the point of the whole thing?
- Wait. Hold it a second, will you?

1019
00:53:21,520 --> 00:53:23,730
Oh, and the Baltimore rooter
is heard from again now...

1020
00:53:23,814 --> 00:53:25,774
and pop-ups are fallin' for base hits
wherever we look.

1021
00:53:25,859 --> 00:53:29,111
Hold it a second. Now, look -
Did the old man say he ran to the door?

1022
00:53:29,195 --> 00:53:32,157
Ran, walked. What's the difference? He got on, didn't he?
I mean, he got there, didn't he?

1023
00:53:32,241 --> 00:53:34,784
- No, now wait a second.
- He said he ran. At least I think he did.

1024
00:53:34,870 --> 00:53:38,289
Look, I don't remember what he said, but I
don't see how he could have run to the door.

1025
00:53:38,373 --> 00:53:40,749
Ηe said he went
from his bedroom to the front door.

1026
00:53:40,834 --> 00:53:42,460
- Now, isn't that enough?
- Where was the bedroom?

1027
00:53:42,545 --> 00:53:44,796
- It was down the hall somewhere.
- I thought you remembered everything.

1028
00:53:44,881 --> 00:53:47,132
- Don't you remember that?
- No.

1029
00:53:47,216 --> 00:53:49,428
Mr. Foreman, I'd like to see
a diagram of the apartment.

1030
00:53:49,553 --> 00:53:52,763
- Why don't we just have 'em run the trial all over again
so you can get everything straight? - Mr. Foreman.

1031
00:53:52,849 --> 00:53:55,477
How come you're the only one in this room
wants to see exhibits all the time?

1032
00:53:55,560 --> 00:53:58,270
- I want to see this one too.
- And I'd like to stop wasting time.

1033
00:53:58,355 --> 00:54:01,191
If we're gonna start wading through all that
nonsense about where the body was found...

1034
00:54:01,275 --> 00:54:03,235
We're not,
not unless somebody else wants to.

1035
00:54:03,319 --> 00:54:05,029
But I'd like to find out if an old man...

1036
00:54:05,112 --> 00:54:07,490
who drags one foot when he walks
'cause he had a stroke last year...

1037
00:54:07,574 --> 00:54:09,992
can get from his bedroom
to his front door in 15 seconds.

1038
00:54:10,077 --> 00:54:11,745
- He said 20 seconds.
- Ηe said 15.

1039
00:54:11,828 --> 00:54:13,997
He said 20 seconds.
What are you trying to distort...

1040
00:54:14,081 --> 00:54:17,335
- He said 15.
- How does he know how long 15 seconds is?

1041
00:54:17,419 --> 00:54:19,086
You can't judge a thing like that.

1042
00:54:19,172 --> 00:54:21,548
- He said 15 seconds.
- He was very positive about it.

1043
00:54:21,633 --> 00:54:23,842
He was an old man.
Half the time he was confused.

1044
00:54:23,928 --> 00:54:26,220
How could he be positive about anything?

1045
00:54:33,897 --> 00:54:38,025
I don't see what you're going to prove here.
The man said he saw the boy running out.

1046
00:54:38,110 --> 00:54:40,277
Well, let's see
if the details bear him out.

1047
00:54:40,363 --> 00:54:43,241
As soon as the body hit the floor,
he said he heard footsteps upstairs...

1048
00:54:43,324 --> 00:54:44,991
running toward the front door...

1049
00:54:45,077 --> 00:54:48,162
heard the upstairs door open,
the footsteps start down the stairs.

1050
00:54:48,247 --> 00:54:50,374
He said he got to his own front door
as fast as he could...

1051
00:54:50,458 --> 00:54:52,543
and he swore it couldn't have been
more than 15 seconds.

1052
00:54:52,628 --> 00:54:54,294
Now, if the killer
began running immediately...

1053
00:54:54,379 --> 00:54:56,589
- Maybe he didn't.
- The old man said he did.

1054
00:54:56,674 --> 00:54:59,384
You ought to be at Atlantic City
at that hairsplitters convention.

1055
00:55:00,678 --> 00:55:02,804
Hey, why don't you stop makin'
smart remarks all the time, huh?

1056
00:55:02,890 --> 00:55:06,016
My friend, for your three dollars a day,
you have to listen to everything, you know?

1057
00:55:06,102 --> 00:55:07,811
Now that you've got that thing in here,
what about it?

1058
00:55:07,895 --> 00:55:10,063
All right. Here's the apartment
where the killing took place.

1059
00:55:10,147 --> 00:55:13,191
The old man's apartment
was directly beneath and exactly the same.

1060
00:55:13,277 --> 00:55:16,487
Here are the el tracks, the bedroom,
living room, kitchen, bathroom.

1061
00:55:16,573 --> 00:55:18,574
Here's the hall. Here are the stairs.

1062
00:55:18,658 --> 00:55:20,909
Now, the old man
was in this bedroom right here.

1063
00:55:20,994 --> 00:55:23,663
He says he crossed to the door
and walked down the hall...

1064
00:55:23,746 --> 00:55:26,709
opened the front door just in time
to see the boy running down the stairs.

1065
00:55:26,792 --> 00:55:30,129
- Am I right so far?
- That's the story, for the 19th time.

1066
00:55:30,213 --> 00:55:33,757
- Fifteen seconds after the body hit the floor.
- Correct.

1067
00:55:33,843 --> 00:55:35,885
Now, let's see. It was...

1068
00:55:35,970 --> 00:55:39,974
It's 12 feet from the bed to the door.
The hall is 43 feet.

1069
00:55:40,057 --> 00:55:43,269
He would have had to walk 12 feet,
open the bedroom door...

1070
00:55:43,353 --> 00:55:46,982
walk 43 feet down and open the front door
all in 15 seconds.

1071
00:55:47,065 --> 00:55:49,776
- Do you think he could have done it?
- Sure he could have done it.

1072
00:55:49,861 --> 00:55:52,447
He can walk only very slowly.
They had to help him into the witness chair.

1073
00:55:52,531 --> 00:55:54,198
You make it sound like a long walk.

1074
00:55:54,282 --> 00:55:56,618
For an old man who had a stroke,
it is a long walk.

1075
00:55:56,702 --> 00:56:00,122
- Oh! What are you doing?
- I'm gonna try it, see how long it took him.

1076
00:56:00,248 --> 00:56:03,586
What do you mean, you want to try it?
Why didn't his lawyer bring it up if it's so important?

1077
00:56:03,711 --> 00:56:07,339
- Maybe he just didn't think about it, huh?
- What do you mean, didn't think of it? You think the man's an idiot or something?

1078
00:56:07,423 --> 00:56:08,966
- It's an obvious thing.
- Did you think of it?

1079
00:56:09,050 --> 00:56:10,717
Listen, smart guy.
Don't matter whether I thought of it.

1080
00:56:10,803 --> 00:56:13,012
He didn't bring it up because he knew it would
hurt his case. What do you think of that?

1081
00:56:13,138 --> 00:56:16,975
Maybe he didn't bring it up because it would have
meant bullying and badgering a helpless old man.

1082
00:56:17,060 --> 00:56:20,396
You know that doesn't sit very well with a jury.
Most lawyers avoid it if they can.

1083
00:56:20,481 --> 00:56:23,191
- So, what kind of a bum is he then?
- That's what I've been asking, buddy.

1084
00:56:23,276 --> 00:56:26,320
Pass me that chair, will you?
Those two chairs are the old man's bed.

1085
00:56:26,403 --> 00:56:29,281
I just paced off 12 feet across the room.
This will be the bedroom door.

1086
00:56:29,367 --> 00:56:31,993
Oh, that's crazy.
You can't recreate a thing like that.

1087
00:56:32,077 --> 00:56:34,287
- I'd like to see it.
- The hall was 43 feet.

1088
00:56:34,372 --> 00:56:36,373
I'll pace from that wall and back again.

1089
00:56:37,668 --> 00:56:41,505
Look, this is absolutely insane.
What are you wasting everybody's time in here for?

1090
00:56:41,588 --> 00:56:44,466
According to you, it'll only take 15 seconds.
Now, we can spare that, see.

1091
00:56:48,430 --> 00:56:50,097
Come on. Knock it off.

1092
00:56:50,183 --> 00:56:51,683
Okay.

1093
00:56:51,767 --> 00:56:53,811
Okay. Okay, killer.

1094
00:56:53,894 --> 00:56:55,479
Yeah.

1095
00:56:57,817 --> 00:56:59,859
Will you stand right there
and mark the front door?

1096
00:56:59,944 --> 00:57:02,445
It was chain-locked according
to the testimony, remember?

1097
00:57:02,530 --> 00:57:04,699
- Has anybody got a watch with a second hand?
- I have.

1098
00:57:04,783 --> 00:57:07,201
When you want me to start, stamp your foot.
That'll be the body falling.

1099
00:57:07,285 --> 00:57:09,203
You can time me from there.

1100
00:57:09,288 --> 00:57:11,373
What are we gonna do, play charades now?

1101
00:57:11,456 --> 00:57:13,500
- Come on! What are we waiting for?
- Okay, I'm ready.

1102
00:57:13,585 --> 00:57:15,503
Well, I want to wait
till the second hand reaches 60.

1103
00:57:15,587 --> 00:57:17,505
Oh, come on.

1104
00:57:24,222 --> 00:57:27,225
Come on. Speed it up.
He could walk twice as fast as that.

1105
00:57:28,685 --> 00:57:31,145
You want me to walk faster than that,
I will.

1106
00:57:48,042 --> 00:57:50,502
Lock. Door. Stop.

1107
00:57:50,587 --> 00:57:52,589
- Right.
- What's the time?

1108
00:57:52,672 --> 00:57:55,924
Uh, exactly 41 seconds.

1109
00:57:56,010 --> 00:57:58,261
This is what I think happened.

1110
00:57:58,345 --> 00:58:01,181
The old man heard the fight between the boy
and his father a few hours earlier.

1111
00:58:01,266 --> 00:58:04,101
Then when he's lying in bed, he heard the
body hit the floor in the boy's apartment...

1112
00:58:04,187 --> 00:58:07,689
heard the woman scream from across the street,
got to his front door as fast as he could...

1113
00:58:07,774 --> 00:58:10,359
heard somebody racing down the stairs
and assumed it was the boy.

1114
00:58:10,443 --> 00:58:12,278
- I think that's possible.
- Assumed?

1115
00:58:12,361 --> 00:58:14,863
Oh.

1116
00:58:14,948 --> 00:58:20,912
Brother, I've seen all kinds of dishonesty in
my day, but this little display takes the cake.

1117
00:58:20,998 --> 00:58:25,710
You all come in here with your hearts bleeding all
over the floor about slum kids and injustice.

1118
00:58:25,794 --> 00:58:27,796
You listen to some fairy tales.

1119
00:58:27,881 --> 00:58:30,173
Suddenly you start getting through
to some of these old ladies.

1120
00:58:30,259 --> 00:58:33,219
Well, you're not getting through to me.
I've had enough.

1121
00:58:33,303 --> 00:58:35,347
What's the matter with you guys?

1122
00:58:35,430 --> 00:58:38,141
You all know he's guilty!
He's got to burn!

1123
00:58:38,226 --> 00:58:40,018
You're letting him slip
through our fingers.

1124
00:58:40,103 --> 00:58:42,314
"Slip through our fingers"?
Are you his executioner?

1125
00:58:42,397 --> 00:58:44,066
I'm one of 'em!

1126
00:58:45,235 --> 00:58:47,069
Perhaps you'd like to pull the switch.

1127
00:58:47,153 --> 00:58:49,155
For this kid, you bet I would.

1128
00:58:49,239 --> 00:58:52,492
I feel sorry for you. What it must
feel like to want to pull the switch.

1129
00:58:53,369 --> 00:58:57,289
Ever since you walked into this room, you've been
acting like a self-appointed public avenger.

1130
00:58:57,374 --> 00:59:01,670
You want to see this boy die because you
personally want it, not because of the facts.

1131
00:59:01,753 --> 00:59:03,922
- You're a sadist.
- You...

1132
00:59:04,006 --> 00:59:07,843
Let me go!
I'll kill him. I'll kill him!

1133
00:59:07,927 --> 00:59:10,346
You don't really mean
you'll kill me, do you?

1134
00:59:17,647 --> 00:59:19,983
Is there anything wrong, gentlemen?
I heard some noise.

1135
00:59:20,067 --> 00:59:24,070
Oh, no. Everything's all right. We're just
- You know, friendly little argument. It's...

1136
00:59:24,155 --> 00:59:27,449
Um, listen, we're through with that diagram.
You can take it if you want.

1137
00:59:28,827 --> 00:59:30,494
Here you are. Thank you.

1138
00:59:36,043 --> 00:59:38,129
What are you lookin' at?

1139
00:59:58,904 --> 01:00:00,947
I suppose somebody
has to start it off again.

1140
01:00:01,032 --> 01:00:04,744
- I beg pardon.
- "I beg pardon." What are you so polite about?

1141
01:00:04,828 --> 01:00:06,913
For the same reason you're not.

1142
01:00:06,997 --> 01:00:08,998
It's the way I was brought up.

1143
01:00:10,919 --> 01:00:12,836
This fighting...

1144
01:00:12,921 --> 01:00:14,963
That's not why we are here, to fight.

1145
01:00:15,049 --> 01:00:17,424
We have a responsibility.

1146
01:00:18,594 --> 01:00:23,183
This, I have always thought,
is a remarkable thing about democracy...

1147
01:00:23,266 --> 01:00:25,142
that we are...

1148
01:00:26,353 --> 01:00:28,939
Uh, what is the word?

1149
01:00:29,022 --> 01:00:32,109
Notified.
That we are notified by mail...

1150
01:00:32,193 --> 01:00:36,530
to come down to this place
to decide on the guilt or innocence...

1151
01:00:36,616 --> 01:00:40,661
of a man we have never heard of before.

1152
01:00:40,744 --> 01:00:45,291
We have nothing to gain or lose
by - by our verdict.

1153
01:00:46,210 --> 01:00:49,338
This is one of the reasons
why we are strong.

1154
01:00:50,632 --> 01:00:53,468
We should not make it a personal thing.

1155
01:00:54,804 --> 01:00:56,471
Thank you.

1156
01:00:57,682 --> 01:00:59,975
If nobody else has an idea,
I may have a cutie here.

1157
01:01:00,059 --> 01:01:02,812
I mean, I haven't given it much thought,
but let's throw it out on the stoop...

1158
01:01:02,895 --> 01:01:04,522
and see if the cat licks it up.

1159
01:01:04,606 --> 01:01:06,941
- The cat licks it up?
- Yeah. If the boy...

1160
01:01:11,448 --> 01:01:13,574
Look how dark it's getting out there.

1161
01:01:13,658 --> 01:01:16,119
I'll bet we're gonna have a storm now.

1162
01:01:17,914 --> 01:01:20,374
Boy, oh, boy. It's really hot, huh?

1163
01:01:21,877 --> 01:01:24,672
Pardon me, but don't you ever sweat?

1164
01:01:26,090 --> 01:01:28,259
No, I don't.

1165
01:01:28,343 --> 01:01:30,345
Well, listen. I, uh...

1166
01:01:30,429 --> 01:01:33,598
I was wondering if, uh, maybe...

1167
01:01:33,682 --> 01:01:35,976
maybe we should take another vote.

1168
01:01:36,060 --> 01:01:40,356
Oh, great. Maybe we can follow this one up
with a little dancing and refreshments, huh?

1169
01:01:40,441 --> 01:01:42,232
- Hmm.
- Mr. Foreman?

1170
01:01:43,027 --> 01:01:46,571
Well, that's okay with me.
Anyone doesn't want to vote?

1171
01:01:46,656 --> 01:01:49,867
- Hey, come on. Come on.
- I'm sorry.

1172
01:01:49,951 --> 01:01:53,455
I think we ought to have an open ballot -
call out our votes, you know.

1173
01:01:53,538 --> 01:01:55,750
Let's see who stands where.

1174
01:01:55,833 --> 01:01:58,335
That sounds fair to me.
Anyone object?

1175
01:02:01,089 --> 01:02:03,799
Okay. I'll call off your jury numbers.
One.

1176
01:02:04,802 --> 01:02:07,596
Oh, that's me. I vote guilty.

1177
01:02:07,681 --> 01:02:09,473
Two?

1178
01:02:09,558 --> 01:02:11,059
Not guilty.

1179
01:02:11,602 --> 01:02:14,438
- Number three?
- Guilty.

1180
01:02:15,440 --> 01:02:16,982
Number four?

1181
01:02:18,485 --> 01:02:20,277
Guilty.

1182
01:02:20,362 --> 01:02:23,114
- Number five?
- Not guilty.

1183
01:02:24,201 --> 01:02:27,495
- Number six?
- Not guilty.

1184
01:02:28,497 --> 01:02:30,165
Number seven?

1185
01:02:30,249 --> 01:02:31,958
Guilty.

1186
01:02:32,043 --> 01:02:34,085
Number eight?

1187
01:02:34,171 --> 01:02:35,838
Not guilty.

1188
01:02:37,174 --> 01:02:40,093
- Number nine?
- Not guilty.

1189
01:02:40,177 --> 01:02:42,346
- Number 10?
- Guilty.

1190
01:02:44,140 --> 01:02:46,183
Number 11?

1191
01:02:46,268 --> 01:02:48,103
Not guilty.

1192
01:02:48,186 --> 01:02:49,687
Number 12?

1193
01:02:50,606 --> 01:02:52,941
Number 12.

1194
01:02:53,026 --> 01:02:54,526
Guilty.

1195
01:03:00,451 --> 01:03:02,536
The vote is now six to six.

1196
01:03:02,620 --> 01:03:05,790
Yeah, right.
And we go into extra innings here, huh?

1197
01:03:08,210 --> 01:03:12,714
Six to six. I'm telling you, some of you
people in here must be out of your minds.

1198
01:03:12,799 --> 01:03:14,633
A kid like that.

1199
01:03:14,717 --> 01:03:17,971
I don't think the kind of boy he is
has anything to do with it.

1200
01:03:18,055 --> 01:03:20,141
The facts are supposed
to determine the case.

1201
01:03:20,224 --> 01:03:22,394
Don't give me that!
I'm sick and tired of facts!

1202
01:03:22,477 --> 01:03:24,479
You can twist them any way you like.
You know what I mean?

1203
01:03:24,563 --> 01:03:27,148
That's exactly the point
this gentleman has been making.

1204
01:03:27,233 --> 01:03:30,153
- Oh!
- I mean, you keep shouting at the top of your lungs.

1205
01:03:31,822 --> 01:03:33,739
I'd like to be a few years younger.

1206
01:03:33,824 --> 01:03:35,741
That man gets on my...

1207
01:03:39,121 --> 01:03:41,957
- My, it's hot in here, isn't it?
- Do you want a drink of water?

1208
01:03:42,041 --> 01:03:45,753
No. No, thanks. Thanks.

1209
01:03:53,598 --> 01:03:55,390
It's gonna rain.

1210
01:03:55,474 --> 01:03:57,725
Well, how'd you figure that out, killer?

1211
01:03:58,979 --> 01:04:00,854
How come you changed your vote?

1212
01:04:00,938 --> 01:04:03,356
Well, it just seemed to me
there was room for doubt.

1213
01:04:03,443 --> 01:04:05,651
You haven't got a leg to stand on.
You know that, I hope.

1214
01:04:05,736 --> 01:04:08,739
I don't feel that way.
There were a lot of details that never came out.

1215
01:04:08,823 --> 01:04:12,368
- Yeah. Well, good luck.
- Oh, come on. You're like everybody else.

1216
01:04:12,452 --> 01:04:14,662
You think too much.
You get mixed up.

1217
01:04:15,916 --> 01:04:19,878
- You know what I mean?
- Now, listen. I don't think you have any right...

1218
01:04:19,961 --> 01:04:22,547
Loudmouth.

1219
01:05:15,276 --> 01:05:17,779
Look at that come down, will you?

1220
01:05:18,948 --> 01:05:20,824
You know...

1221
01:05:20,907 --> 01:05:23,410
this reminds me of a storm we had last...

1222
01:05:23,495 --> 01:05:26,955
Oh, when was that? November...

1223
01:05:27,040 --> 01:05:30,126
I don't know. Something.
It was quite a storm we had there.

1224
01:05:30,211 --> 01:05:32,587
It was right in the middle of a game.

1225
01:05:32,672 --> 01:05:35,299
Uh, we were behind 7-6...

1226
01:05:35,383 --> 01:05:37,969
but we just started to move the ball,
right off the tackle.

1227
01:05:38,053 --> 01:05:40,847
Started cutting right -
slash here and slash right in...

1228
01:05:40,931 --> 01:05:42,725
cut right through.

1229
01:05:42,809 --> 01:05:45,311
And, uh...

1230
01:05:45,395 --> 01:05:47,604
We had this kid Slattery, you know?

1231
01:05:48,774 --> 01:05:52,152
A real - He was an ox.
You know, a real ox.

1232
01:05:52,236 --> 01:05:54,739
I wish I had another one just like him.

1233
01:05:54,823 --> 01:05:59,327
I forgot to tell you. I'm the assistant head
coach at the Andrew J. McCorkle High School.

1234
01:05:59,412 --> 01:06:01,496
- Oh, yeah?
- That's out in Queens.

1235
01:06:01,581 --> 01:06:04,333
And, uh, anyway...

1236
01:06:04,418 --> 01:06:06,502
we're starting to move along real nice.

1237
01:06:06,586 --> 01:06:09,756
Their whole line is just -
they're just coming apart.

1238
01:06:11,050 --> 01:06:14,804
And it starts to come down
cats and dogs, just like this.

1239
01:06:14,888 --> 01:06:17,514
Just whoosh - you know, right down.

1240
01:06:18,810 --> 01:06:22,188
Well, that was murder, you know?

1241
01:06:22,271 --> 01:06:24,858
I swear, I - I nearly bawled.

1242
01:06:24,941 --> 01:06:27,277
You just - You couldn't go nowhere.

1243
01:06:28,529 --> 01:06:29,864
Well.

1244
01:06:45,508 --> 01:06:48,009
Hey, what is it with this fan here?
How come...

1245
01:06:55,769 --> 01:06:57,521
Hey! Ηuh?

1246
01:06:57,605 --> 01:07:00,900
Must have been
on the same switch with the lights.

1247
01:07:01,902 --> 01:07:05,072
Well, things are looking up here, huh?

1248
01:07:05,739 --> 01:07:07,241
Yeah, huh?

1249
01:07:12,081 --> 01:07:14,082
Boy. That's better.

1250
01:07:20,757 --> 01:07:22,258
Hey!

1251
01:07:22,343 --> 01:07:24,010
Two points.

1252
01:07:28,016 --> 01:07:30,017
Any of you guys ever go to the Garden?

1253
01:07:32,312 --> 01:07:35,190
That's a damn stupid thing to do.

1254
01:07:35,275 --> 01:07:37,443
Oh, I'm sorry. I, uh...

1255
01:07:38,486 --> 01:07:39,862
You know?

1256
01:07:41,573 --> 01:07:43,073
Pardon me.

1257
01:07:44,160 --> 01:07:46,495
Well, how do you like it?
Even Steven.

1258
01:07:46,580 --> 01:07:48,957
Pretty surprising, isn't it?

1259
01:07:49,040 --> 01:07:50,542
Yes.

1260
01:07:52,335 --> 01:07:55,839
Say, that business before,
when that tall guy - what's-his-name...

1261
01:07:55,923 --> 01:07:58,634
was trying to bait me -
That doesn't prove anything.

1262
01:07:58,719 --> 01:08:01,305
I'm a pretty excitable person.

1263
01:08:01,388 --> 01:08:05,225
I mean, where does he come off calling me
a public avenger, sadist and everything?

1264
01:08:05,311 --> 01:08:08,813
Anyone in his right mind
would blow his stack, huh?

1265
01:08:08,897 --> 01:08:11,191
He was just trying to bait me.

1266
01:08:11,274 --> 01:08:13,276
He did an excellent job.

1267
01:08:16,072 --> 01:08:18,283
I'll tell you what I think.
We're going nowhere here.

1268
01:08:18,366 --> 01:08:20,910
I'm ready to walk into court right now
and declare a hung jury.

1269
01:08:20,995 --> 01:08:22,829
There's no point in this thing
going on any more.

1270
01:08:22,914 --> 01:08:24,248
Yeah. I go for that too.

1271
01:08:24,332 --> 01:08:27,168
Listen, let's take it in to the judge and let
the kid take his chances with 12 other guys.

1272
01:08:27,252 --> 01:08:30,087
I don't think the judge will accept a hung jury.
We haven't been in here very long.

1273
01:08:30,172 --> 01:08:31,840
Well, let's find out.

1274
01:08:31,925 --> 01:08:33,634
I'm not in favor of that.

1275
01:08:33,718 --> 01:08:36,929
Listen. This kid wouldn't stand a chance
with another jury, and you know it.

1276
01:08:37,013 --> 01:08:39,849
Come on! We're hung. Nobody's gonna
change his vote. Let's take it inside.

1277
01:08:39,935 --> 01:08:42,144
You still don't think there's room
for reasonable doubt?

1278
01:08:42,228 --> 01:08:43,521
No, I don't.

1279
01:08:43,605 --> 01:08:44,897
Pardon.

1280
01:08:44,981 --> 01:08:48,234
Maybe you don't fully understand
the term "reasonable doubt."

1281
01:08:48,319 --> 01:08:50,863
What do you mean I don't understand?

1282
01:08:51,948 --> 01:08:53,907
Boy, how do ya like this guy?

1283
01:08:53,992 --> 01:08:55,660
I'm tellin' ya, they're all alike.

1284
01:08:55,743 --> 01:08:58,580
They come over here, running for their life,
and before they can take a deep breath...

1285
01:08:58,664 --> 01:09:01,041
they're telling us how
to run the show, huh?

1286
01:09:01,125 --> 01:09:02,918
Boy, the arrogance of this guy.

1287
01:09:03,002 --> 01:09:07,590
Hey, all right. Let's stop
the arguing for about two minutes in here.

1288
01:09:07,675 --> 01:09:10,052
Now, who's got something
constructive to say?

1289
01:09:10,136 --> 01:09:13,681
I'd like to go over something,
if you gentlemen don't mind.

1290
01:09:13,766 --> 01:09:16,434
An important point for the prosecution
was the fact...

1291
01:09:16,519 --> 01:09:19,272
that after the boy claimed
he'd been at the movies...

1292
01:09:19,355 --> 01:09:21,357
during the hours
that the killing took place...

1293
01:09:21,440 --> 01:09:25,320
couldn't remember the names of the movies
or the stars who appeared in them.

1294
01:09:25,404 --> 01:09:27,906
This gentleman here has put up that point
in here several times.

1295
01:09:27,991 --> 01:09:29,449
That's correct.

1296
01:09:29,534 --> 01:09:31,411
It was the only alibi the boy offered...

1297
01:09:31,494 --> 01:09:33,997
and he himself couldn't back it up
with any details at all.

1298
01:09:34,080 --> 01:09:37,334
Putting yourself in the boy's place,
do you think you could remember details...

1299
01:09:37,419 --> 01:09:40,879
after an upsetting experience such as
being slapped in the face by your father?

1300
01:09:40,964 --> 01:09:44,175
I think so, if there were
any special details to remember.

1301
01:09:44,260 --> 01:09:47,430
The boy couldn't remember the names of the movies
he saw because be wasn't there that night.

1302
01:09:47,513 --> 01:09:49,557
According to
the police testimony in court...

1303
01:09:49,640 --> 01:09:52,768
the boy was questioned by the detectives
in the kitchen of his apartment...

1304
01:09:52,853 --> 01:09:55,771
while the body of his father
was lying on the floor in the bedroom.

1305
01:09:55,857 --> 01:09:58,442
Do you think you could remember details
under those circumstances?

1306
01:09:58,526 --> 01:10:00,527
- I do.
- Under great emotional stress?

1307
01:10:00,612 --> 01:10:03,115
- Under great emotional stress.
- He remembered them correctly in court.

1308
01:10:03,198 --> 01:10:05,158
He named the pictures
and the stars who played in them.

1309
01:10:05,243 --> 01:10:08,412
Yes. His lawyer took great pains
to bring that out.

1310
01:10:08,496 --> 01:10:11,040
He had three months from the night
of the murder to the day of the trial...

1311
01:10:11,125 --> 01:10:12,751
in which to memorize them.

1312
01:10:12,835 --> 01:10:15,504
It's not difficult for a lawyer to find out
what played at a particular theater...

1313
01:10:15,588 --> 01:10:17,255
on a particular night.

1314
01:10:17,341 --> 01:10:20,968
I'll take the testimony of the policemen who
interrogated the boy right after the murder...

1315
01:10:21,053 --> 01:10:23,471
when he couldn't remember
a thing about the movies...

1316
01:10:23,557 --> 01:10:25,474
great emotional stress or not.

1317
01:10:25,558 --> 01:10:28,853
- I'd like to ask you a personal question.
- Go ahead.

1318
01:10:28,937 --> 01:10:32,190
- Where were you last night?
- I was home.

1319
01:10:32,274 --> 01:10:34,818
- How about the night before that?
- Come on! What is this?

1320
01:10:34,903 --> 01:10:36,236
No, it's all right.

1321
01:10:36,321 --> 01:10:38,865
I left the office at 8:30
and went straight home and to bed.

1322
01:10:38,949 --> 01:10:40,617
And the night before that?

1323
01:10:40,700 --> 01:10:43,119
That was, uh, Tuesday night?

1324
01:10:43,203 --> 01:10:45,205
The night of the bridge tournament.
I played bridge.

1325
01:10:45,289 --> 01:10:46,624
Monday night?

1326
01:10:46,708 --> 01:10:49,919
When you get down
to New Year's Eve, 1954, let me know, huh?

1327
01:10:51,922 --> 01:10:53,882
Monday night?

1328
01:10:55,134 --> 01:10:58,137
Monday night, uh,
my wife and I went to the movies.

1329
01:10:58,222 --> 01:10:59,847
- What did you see?
- The Scarlet Circle.

1330
01:10:59,932 --> 01:11:03,184
- It was a clever whodunit.
- What was the second feature?

1331
01:11:03,268 --> 01:11:05,896
The, um...

1332
01:11:05,980 --> 01:11:08,650
I'll tell you in a minute. The, uh...

1333
01:11:08,733 --> 01:11:12,904
Remarkable Mrs., uh, something...

1334
01:11:12,989 --> 01:11:15,449
The...

1335
01:11:15,534 --> 01:11:18,202
Mrs. Bainbridge.
The Remarkable Mrs. Bainbridge.

1336
01:11:18,287 --> 01:11:21,039
I saw that.
It's called The Amazing Mrs. Bainbridge.

1337
01:11:22,333 --> 01:11:24,711
Uh, yes. The Amazing Mrs. Bainbridge.
I think that's right.

1338
01:11:24,794 --> 01:11:27,296
Who was in The Amazing Mrs. Bainbridge?

1339
01:11:27,381 --> 01:11:31,050
Barbara... Long, I think it was.

1340
01:11:31,136 --> 01:11:33,137
A dark, very pretty girl.

1341
01:11:34,472 --> 01:11:36,975
Ling or Long - something like that.

1342
01:11:37,058 --> 01:11:40,270
- Who else?
- I'd never heard of them before.

1343
01:11:40,354 --> 01:11:44,776
It was a very inexpensive second feature
with, uh, unknown...

1344
01:11:44,860 --> 01:11:47,988
And you weren't under
an emotional stress, were you?

1345
01:11:50,908 --> 01:11:53,035
No.

1346
01:11:53,119 --> 01:11:54,788
I wasn't.

1347
01:11:56,665 --> 01:11:58,417
I think the point is made.

1348
01:11:58,500 --> 01:12:01,253
Big point!

1349
01:12:01,337 --> 01:12:03,505
You can talk till your tongue
is draggin' on the floor.

1350
01:12:03,590 --> 01:12:07,678
The boy is guilty, period.
You know what I mean, my friend?

1351
01:12:07,762 --> 01:12:11,015
- Who's got those cough drops?
- They're all gone, my friend.

1352
01:12:13,018 --> 01:12:15,270
Oh, boy. Look at that rain.

1353
01:12:15,353 --> 01:12:17,731
There goes your ball game.

1354
01:12:17,815 --> 01:12:20,233
It's only a shower.

1355
01:12:20,319 --> 01:12:22,486
Besides, they got the infield covered.

1356
01:12:22,572 --> 01:12:25,740
Right. Say, could I see that knife
a second, please?

1357
01:12:28,536 --> 01:12:30,871
Well, we're still tied up six to six.

1358
01:12:30,956 --> 01:12:32,957
Who's got a suggestion?

1359
01:12:33,042 --> 01:12:35,043
It's five after 6:00.
Let's get some dinner.

1360
01:12:35,127 --> 01:12:37,587
Why don't we wait till 7:00,
give it another hour, huh?

1361
01:12:37,671 --> 01:12:39,800
Okay with me.

1362
01:12:39,883 --> 01:12:42,051
Uh, there's something I'd like to say.

1363
01:12:42,135 --> 01:12:45,680
I mean, it's been bothering me a little,
and as long as we're stuck.

1364
01:12:45,764 --> 01:12:49,644
Well, there was this whole business
about the stab wound and how it was made...

1365
01:12:49,727 --> 01:12:51,354
the downward angle of it, you know?

1366
01:12:51,438 --> 01:12:53,440
Don't tell me we're gonna
start with that again.

1367
01:12:53,524 --> 01:12:55,150
They've been over it and over it.

1368
01:12:55,234 --> 01:12:57,528
Well, I know they did,
but I don't go along with it.

1369
01:12:57,612 --> 01:13:01,616
Now, the boy was 5 feet 7 inches tall.
His father was 6'2...

1370
01:13:01,699 --> 01:13:03,868
That's a difference of seven inches.

1371
01:13:03,953 --> 01:13:06,621
It's a very awkward thing to stab down
into the chest of someone...

1372
01:13:06,706 --> 01:13:08,707
who's more than half a foot
taller than you are.

1373
01:13:08,792 --> 01:13:10,918
Give me that.

1374
01:13:11,003 --> 01:13:13,796
I'll give you a demonstration.
Somebody get up.

1375
01:13:15,175 --> 01:13:17,092
You...

1376
01:13:21,599 --> 01:13:24,308
I want you to watch this 'cause
I don't want to have to do it again.

1377
01:13:24,394 --> 01:13:27,145
I'll make myself about six
or seven inches shorter, okay?

1378
01:13:27,230 --> 01:13:30,358
- It's about right. Maybe a little more.
- Okay. A little more.

1379
01:13:38,159 --> 01:13:40,579
That's not funny.

1380
01:13:42,665 --> 01:13:46,502
Now, nobody's hurt. Right?

1381
01:13:47,170 --> 01:13:48,963
Right. Nobody hurt.

1382
01:13:52,426 --> 01:13:57,222
Now, this is the way I'd stab a man
who was taller than I was.

1383
01:13:57,307 --> 01:13:59,767
Look at the angle - down and in.

1384
01:13:59,853 --> 01:14:01,937
And this is the way it was done.

1385
01:14:02,021 --> 01:14:04,190
Now tell me I'm wrong.

1386
01:14:06,401 --> 01:14:09,821
- Down and in. I guess there's no argument.
- Hold it a minute, will ya?

1387
01:14:09,906 --> 01:14:11,740
Can you give me that?

1388
01:14:12,743 --> 01:14:14,660
Boy, I hate these things.

1389
01:14:14,744 --> 01:14:16,412
- Did you ever see a knife fight?
- No.

1390
01:14:16,496 --> 01:14:18,080
- You?
- No.

1391
01:14:18,165 --> 01:14:20,958
Anybody here ever see a knife fight?

1392
01:14:21,045 --> 01:14:23,837
Well, I have.
You know, on my back stoop...

1393
01:14:23,923 --> 01:14:26,256
the lot across the street, backyard.

1394
01:14:26,342 --> 01:14:28,760
Switchblades came
with the neighborhood where I lived.

1395
01:14:28,844 --> 01:14:32,097
It's funny I never thought of it before.
I guess you try to forget those things.

1396
01:14:32,182 --> 01:14:35,559
- How do you use a switchblade?
- Well, you'd never use it like this.

1397
01:14:37,313 --> 01:14:39,607
See, you use too much time
switching hands.

1398
01:14:41,359 --> 01:14:43,860
Here's how - underhanded.

1399
01:14:46,574 --> 01:14:49,619
Anyone who's ever used a switch knife
wouldn't handle it any other way.

1400
01:14:49,702 --> 01:14:52,329
- Are you sure?
- I'm sure.

1401
01:14:52,413 --> 01:14:54,247
That's why they're made to open like that.

1402
01:14:54,333 --> 01:14:56,961
- You'd say the boy was pretty handy with a knife?
- Mm-hmm.

1403
01:14:57,044 --> 01:15:00,214
You think he could have made
the kind of wound that killed his father?

1404
01:15:00,297 --> 01:15:04,219
No. Not with the experience he'd had
all his life handling these things.

1405
01:15:04,302 --> 01:15:06,304
I feel he'd have gone for him underhanded.

1406
01:15:06,388 --> 01:15:09,432
How do you know? Were you
in the room when the father was killed?

1407
01:15:09,517 --> 01:15:11,519
No. Neither was anybody else.

1408
01:15:11,603 --> 01:15:14,814
So what are you giving us all this
mumbo jumbo for? I don't believe it.

1409
01:15:14,899 --> 01:15:18,152
I don't think you can determine what type of
wound the boy might or might not have made...

1410
01:15:18,236 --> 01:15:20,862
simply because he knew
how to handle a knife.

1411
01:15:20,948 --> 01:15:23,282
What do you think?

1412
01:15:23,367 --> 01:15:25,451
- I don't know.
- What do you mean you don't know?

1413
01:15:25,537 --> 01:15:27,371
I don't know.

1414
01:15:31,585 --> 01:15:33,586
How about you?

1415
01:15:33,671 --> 01:15:37,424
I don't know about the rest of them, but I'm getting a
little tired of this yackety-yackin' back and forth.

1416
01:15:37,509 --> 01:15:40,969
It's gettin' us nowhere.
So I guess I'll have to break it up.

1417
01:15:41,055 --> 01:15:43,598
I change my vote to not guilty.

1418
01:15:43,682 --> 01:15:47,019
- You what?
- You heard me. I've had enough.

1419
01:15:47,103 --> 01:15:49,564
What do you mean you've had enough?
That's no answer!

1420
01:15:49,648 --> 01:15:53,609
Hey, listen. You just take care
of yourself, huh? You know?

1421
01:15:53,694 --> 01:15:57,656
He's right. That's not an answer.

1422
01:15:57,741 --> 01:16:00,702
What kind of a man are you?

1423
01:16:00,786 --> 01:16:03,912
You have sat here and voted guilty
with everyone else...

1424
01:16:03,999 --> 01:16:08,251
because there are some baseball tickets
burning a hole in your pocket.

1425
01:16:08,336 --> 01:16:12,590
And now you've changed your vote because you
say you're sick of all the talking here?

1426
01:16:13,593 --> 01:16:15,052
Now listen, buddy!

1427
01:16:15,136 --> 01:16:19,806
Who tells you that you have the right
to play like this with a man's life?

1428
01:16:19,892 --> 01:16:22,393
- Don't you care -
- Now wait a minute!

1429
01:16:22,478 --> 01:16:26,483
- You can't talk like that to me!
- I can talk like that to you.

1430
01:16:26,566 --> 01:16:28,443
If you want to vote not guilty...

1431
01:16:28,526 --> 01:16:30,904
then do it because you are convinced
the man is not guilty...

1432
01:16:30,988 --> 01:16:32,781
not because you've had enough.

1433
01:16:32,865 --> 01:16:35,451
And if you think he is guilty,
then vote that way.

1434
01:16:35,535 --> 01:16:38,746
Or don't you have the guts
to do what you think is right?

1435
01:16:38,830 --> 01:16:41,083
- Now listen.
- Guilty or not guilty?

1436
01:16:41,876 --> 01:16:45,463
- I told you, not guilty.
- Why?

1437
01:16:47,132 --> 01:16:48,758
Look, I don't have to...

1438
01:16:48,842 --> 01:16:51,969
You do have to! Say it! Why?

1439
01:16:52,055 --> 01:16:54,515
All right. I don't, uh, think he's guilty.

1440
01:17:04,027 --> 01:17:05,653
I want another vote.

1441
01:17:05,737 --> 01:17:08,240
Okay. There's another vote called for.

1442
01:17:08,324 --> 01:17:11,201
I guess the quickest way is a show of hands.
Anyone object?

1443
01:17:11,284 --> 01:17:14,204
Okay. All those voting not guilty,
raise your hands.

1444
01:17:15,124 --> 01:17:20,295
One, two, three, four,
five, six, seven...

1445
01:17:23,134 --> 01:17:24,801
eight.

1446
01:17:28,723 --> 01:17:30,850
Um, nine.

1447
01:17:31,851 --> 01:17:36,857
Um, all those voting guilty,
raise your hands.

1448
01:17:36,941 --> 01:17:39,318
One, two, three.

1449
01:17:39,402 --> 01:17:41,903
Well, the vote's nine to three
in favor of acquittal.

1450
01:17:42,906 --> 01:17:45,074
I don't understand you people!

1451
01:17:45,158 --> 01:17:47,327
I mean, all these picky little points
you keep bringing up.

1452
01:17:47,411 --> 01:17:50,747
They don't mean nothing!
You saw this kid just like I did.

1453
01:17:50,832 --> 01:17:54,334
You're not gonna tell me you believe
that phony story about losing the knife...

1454
01:17:54,419 --> 01:17:56,421
and that business
about being at the movies.

1455
01:17:56,505 --> 01:17:59,507
Look, you know how these people lie.
It's born in them.

1456
01:17:59,593 --> 01:18:01,635
I mean, what the heck.
I don't have to tell you.

1457
01:18:01,720 --> 01:18:03,680
They don't know what the truth is.

1458
01:18:03,764 --> 01:18:07,475
And let me tell you, they don't need
any real big reason to kill someone either.

1459
01:18:07,560 --> 01:18:09,312
No, sir.

1460
01:18:09,396 --> 01:18:12,440
They get drunk!
Oh, they're real big drinkers, all of 'em.

1461
01:18:12,524 --> 01:18:15,693
You know that.
And bang - someone's lying in the gutter.

1462
01:18:15,778 --> 01:18:18,780
Well, nobody's blaming them for it.
That's the way they are, by nature.

1463
01:18:18,865 --> 01:18:20,949
You know what I mean? Violent!

1464
01:18:21,035 --> 01:18:22,534
Where are you going?

1465
01:18:22,620 --> 01:18:25,622
Ηuman life don't mean
as much to them as it does to us.

1466
01:18:26,625 --> 01:18:29,627
Look! They're lushing it up
and fighting all the time...

1467
01:18:29,711 --> 01:18:31,713
and if somebody gets killed,
so somebody gets killed!

1468
01:18:31,796 --> 01:18:33,172
They don't care!

1469
01:18:33,257 --> 01:18:35,467
Oh, sure, there's some good things
about 'em too.

1470
01:18:35,551 --> 01:18:37,511
Look, I'm the first one to say that.

1471
01:18:37,596 --> 01:18:40,890
I've known a couple who were okay, but
that's the exception, you know what I mean?

1472
01:18:40,973 --> 01:18:44,728
Most of 'em, it's like they have no feelings.
They can do anything.

1473
01:18:44,812 --> 01:18:47,396
What's going on here?

1474
01:18:47,483 --> 01:18:49,525
I'm - I'm trying to tell ya...

1475
01:18:49,610 --> 01:18:51,611
you're making a big mistake, you people.

1476
01:18:51,695 --> 01:18:54,697
This kid is a liar!
I know it. I know all about them.

1477
01:18:56,409 --> 01:18:58,577
Listen to me.
They're no good.

1478
01:18:58,662 --> 01:19:00,996
There's not a one of 'em who's any good.

1479
01:19:03,042 --> 01:19:05,502
I mean, what -
What's happening in here?

1480
01:19:05,587 --> 01:19:07,837
I'm speaking my piece, and you...

1481
01:19:09,049 --> 01:19:10,716
Listen to me.

1482
01:19:11,802 --> 01:19:13,262
I...

1483
01:19:13,346 --> 01:19:15,807
We're - This kid on trial here, his type...

1484
01:19:15,890 --> 01:19:17,892
Well, don't you know about them?

1485
01:19:19,853 --> 01:19:23,315
Th-There's - There's a danger here.

1486
01:19:23,400 --> 01:19:25,484
These people are dangerous.

1487
01:19:25,568 --> 01:19:28,612
They're... wild.

1488
01:19:28,698 --> 01:19:30,615
Listen to me.

1489
01:19:30,700 --> 01:19:33,035
- Listen.
- I have.

1490
01:19:33,119 --> 01:19:36,122
Now sit down
and don't open your mouth again.

1491
01:19:40,044 --> 01:19:42,796
I was only trying to... tell you.

1492
01:20:19,298 --> 01:20:23,595
It's always difficult to keep personal
prejudice out of a thing like this.

1493
01:20:24,721 --> 01:20:28,725
Wherever you run into it,
prejudice always obscures the truth.

1494
01:20:30,311 --> 01:20:32,688
I don't really know what the truth is.

1495
01:20:32,773 --> 01:20:35,692
I don't suppose anybody
will ever really know.

1496
01:20:36,986 --> 01:20:40,948
Nine of us now seem to feel
that the defendant is innocent.

1497
01:20:41,032 --> 01:20:44,036
But we're just gambling on probabilities.

1498
01:20:44,119 --> 01:20:46,080
We may be wrong.

1499
01:20:46,163 --> 01:20:48,540
We may be trying to let
a guilty man go free.

1500
01:20:48,625 --> 01:20:50,085
I don't know.

1501
01:20:50,168 --> 01:20:52,170
Nobody really can.

1502
01:20:52,253 --> 01:20:54,631
But we have a reasonable doubt...

1503
01:20:54,714 --> 01:20:58,219
and that's something
that's very valuable in our system.

1504
01:20:58,302 --> 01:21:02,848
No jury can declare a man guilty
unless it's sure.

1505
01:21:04,310 --> 01:21:06,686
We nine can't understand...

1506
01:21:06,771 --> 01:21:09,481
how you three are still so sure.

1507
01:21:10,317 --> 01:21:12,318
- Maybe you can tell us.
- I'll try.

1508
01:21:13,695 --> 01:21:17,199
You've made some excellent points, but I
still believe the boy is guilty of murder...

1509
01:21:17,283 --> 01:21:18,993
and I have two reasons.

1510
01:21:19,077 --> 01:21:22,206
One, the evidence
given by the woman across the street...

1511
01:21:22,289 --> 01:21:24,916
who actually saw the murder committed.

1512
01:21:24,999 --> 01:21:27,586
As far as I'm concerned,
that's the most important testimony.

1513
01:21:27,670 --> 01:21:30,923
And two, the fact that she
described the stabbing by saying...

1514
01:21:31,007 --> 01:21:36,638
she saw the boy raise his arm over his head
and stab down into the father's chest.

1515
01:21:36,722 --> 01:21:38,766
She saw him do it the wrong way.

1516
01:21:38,850 --> 01:21:40,769
That's absolutely right.

1517
01:21:40,853 --> 01:21:43,438
Let's talk about this woman for a moment.

1518
01:21:43,523 --> 01:21:46,608
She said she went to bed
about 11:00 that night.

1519
01:21:46,693 --> 01:21:50,279
Her bed was next to the window,
and she could look out while lying down...

1520
01:21:50,364 --> 01:21:54,452
and see directly into the boy's room
across the street.

1521
01:21:54,535 --> 01:21:57,163
She tossed and turned for over an hour,
unable to sleep.

1522
01:21:57,247 --> 01:22:01,418
Finally, she turned toward the window
at about 10 minutes after 12:00...

1523
01:22:01,501 --> 01:22:06,631
and, as she looked out, she saw the killing
through the windows of a passing el train.

1524
01:22:06,717 --> 01:22:09,427
She said the lights went out
immediately after the killing...

1525
01:22:09,511 --> 01:22:14,308
but that she got a good look at the boy
in the act of stabbing his father.

1526
01:22:15,310 --> 01:22:19,147
As far as I can see it,
this is unshakable testimony.

1527
01:22:19,898 --> 01:22:22,568
- Well, that's the whole case.
- What do you think?

1528
01:22:27,949 --> 01:22:29,618
How about you?

1529
01:22:31,244 --> 01:22:33,705
I-I don't know.

1530
01:22:33,790 --> 01:22:35,791
So much evidence to sift.

1531
01:22:35,876 --> 01:22:37,835
This is a pretty complicated business.

1532
01:22:37,921 --> 01:22:41,715
Frankly, I don't see
how you can vote for acquittal.

1533
01:22:41,799 --> 01:22:44,134
It's not so easy to arrange
all the evidence in order.

1534
01:22:44,220 --> 01:22:46,262
You can throw out
all the other evidence!

1535
01:22:46,347 --> 01:22:49,933
The woman saw him do it!
What else do you want?

1536
01:22:50,018 --> 01:22:51,894
- Yeah, well, maybe -
- Let's vote on it.

1537
01:22:51,978 --> 01:22:54,146
Okay. There's another vote called for.

1538
01:22:54,232 --> 01:22:56,066
Anybody object?

1539
01:22:56,149 --> 01:22:59,194
All right. I'm changing my vote.
He's guilty.

1540
01:22:59,278 --> 01:23:01,696
Anybody else?
The vote is eight to four.

1541
01:23:01,781 --> 01:23:05,368
Why is this such a personal triumph
for you - this one vote?

1542
01:23:05,451 --> 01:23:08,914
Okay. I say we're a hung jury.
I say we take it in to the judge.

1543
01:23:08,997 --> 01:23:11,708
Ηow about it?
I want to hear arguments.

1544
01:23:11,793 --> 01:23:14,294
You, you're the leader of the cause.
What about it?

1545
01:23:16,549 --> 01:23:18,384
Let's go over it again.

1546
01:23:18,468 --> 01:23:20,386
We've been over it again!

1547
01:23:20,470 --> 01:23:25,267
The boy in the gray flannel suit here is bouncin'
backwards and forwards like a tennis ball.

1548
01:23:25,350 --> 01:23:29,188
No point in getting nasty
and trying to turn this into a contest.

1549
01:23:31,148 --> 01:23:32,608
Okay.

1550
01:23:32,692 --> 01:23:35,736
Maybe we can talk about
setting some kind of time limit.

1551
01:23:35,822 --> 01:23:37,947
Yeah, once around for the deal, huh?

1552
01:23:38,658 --> 01:23:42,412
It's a quarter after 6:00.

1553
01:23:42,496 --> 01:23:44,455
Someone before mentioned 7:00.

1554
01:23:44,540 --> 01:23:46,916
I think that's a point at which
we might begin to discuss...

1555
01:23:47,002 --> 01:23:50,254
the question of whether
we're a hung jury or not.

1556
01:23:50,337 --> 01:23:52,006
Don't you feel well?

1557
01:23:53,342 --> 01:23:55,303
I feel perfectly well, thank you.

1558
01:23:55,386 --> 01:23:58,096
I was saying that 7:00
would be a reasonable time.

1559
01:23:58,181 --> 01:24:01,100
Uh, the reason I asked about that
was because, uh...

1560
01:24:01,184 --> 01:24:02,768
you were rubbing your nose like...

1561
01:24:02,853 --> 01:24:05,522
Oh, I'm sorry for interrupting...

1562
01:24:05,606 --> 01:24:08,817
but you made a gesture
that reminded me of something.

1563
01:24:08,901 --> 01:24:10,944
I'm trying to settle something here.
Do you mind?

1564
01:24:11,030 --> 01:24:13,031
Well, I think this is important.

1565
01:24:14,116 --> 01:24:15,909
Thank you.

1566
01:24:15,994 --> 01:24:18,622
Now then,
I'm sure you'll pardon me for this...

1567
01:24:18,705 --> 01:24:21,625
but I was wondering why
you were rubbing your nose like that.

1568
01:24:21,708 --> 01:24:23,375
Oh, come on, will ya?

1569
01:24:23,461 --> 01:24:27,632
At this point, I happen to be talking
to the gentleman sitting next to you!

1570
01:24:27,716 --> 01:24:30,968
Now, why were you rubbing
your nose like that?

1571
01:24:31,053 --> 01:24:35,140
Well, if it's any of your business, I was
rubbing it because it bothers me a little.

1572
01:24:35,224 --> 01:24:36,850
Oh. I'm sorry.

1573
01:24:36,934 --> 01:24:40,813
- Is it - Is it because of your eyeglasses?
- It is.

1574
01:24:40,898 --> 01:24:42,649
Now can we get on to something else?

1575
01:24:42,733 --> 01:24:47,322
Your eyeglasses made those two
deep impressions on the sides of your nose.

1576
01:24:47,405 --> 01:24:49,574
I hadn't noticed that before.

1577
01:24:49,659 --> 01:24:53,161
- That must be annoying.
- It is very annoying.

1578
01:24:53,246 --> 01:24:55,163
Well, I wouldn't know about that.

1579
01:24:55,247 --> 01:24:58,584
I've never worn eyeglasses.
Twenty-twenty.

1580
01:24:58,669 --> 01:25:01,213
Listen, will you come on already
with the optometrist bit?

1581
01:25:03,131 --> 01:25:06,678
The woman who testified
that she saw the killing...

1582
01:25:06,761 --> 01:25:10,306
had those same marks
on the sides of her nose.

1583
01:25:11,308 --> 01:25:13,519
Holy smokes! You know, he's right.

1584
01:25:13,603 --> 01:25:15,269
Please.

1585
01:25:15,356 --> 01:25:19,109
Just give me a minute,
and I'll be finished.

1586
01:25:19,193 --> 01:25:22,028
I don't know if anyone else
noticed that about her.

1587
01:25:22,113 --> 01:25:25,991
I didn't think of it then,
but I've been going over her face...

1588
01:25:27,035 --> 01:25:29,162
in my mind.

1589
01:25:29,246 --> 01:25:31,248
She had those same marks.

1590
01:25:32,250 --> 01:25:36,421
- She kept rubbing them in court.
- He's right. She did do that a lot.

1591
01:25:37,465 --> 01:25:42,135
This woman was about, uh -
about 45 years old.

1592
01:25:42,221 --> 01:25:46,181
She was making a tremendous effort
to look 35...

1593
01:25:46,267 --> 01:25:48,476
for her first public appearance.

1594
01:25:48,560 --> 01:25:51,813
Heavy makeup, dyed hair...

1595
01:25:51,898 --> 01:25:55,776
brand-new clothes that should have
been worn by a younger woman.

1596
01:25:55,862 --> 01:25:57,529
No glasses.

1597
01:25:57,613 --> 01:25:59,281
No, women do that.

1598
01:25:59,364 --> 01:26:01,783
See if you can get the
mental picture of it.

1599
01:26:01,868 --> 01:26:03,702
What do you mean, no glasses?

1600
01:26:03,787 --> 01:26:06,497
How do you know whether she wore glasses?
Just 'cause she was rubbing her nose?

1601
01:26:06,582 --> 01:26:08,792
Now, she had those marks. I saw 'em.

1602
01:26:08,877 --> 01:26:10,795
So what?
What do ya think that means?

1603
01:26:10,879 --> 01:26:14,089
- Listen, I'm getting so sick of your yelling in here!
- Come on. Forget it.

1604
01:26:14,175 --> 01:26:17,177
Hey, listen. Listen, he's right.
I saw them too.

1605
01:26:17,261 --> 01:26:20,389
I was the closest one to her. She had these,
uh - these things on the side of her nose.

1606
01:26:20,474 --> 01:26:23,685
- What do you call those on the side?
- Well, what point are you making here?

1607
01:26:23,769 --> 01:26:27,648
She had dyed hair, marks on her nose.
Well, what does that mean?

1608
01:26:27,732 --> 01:26:32,028
Could those marks be made
by anything other than eyeglasses?

1609
01:26:35,616 --> 01:26:37,950
No, they couldn't.

1610
01:26:38,036 --> 01:26:40,036
I didn't see any marks!

1611
01:26:41,664 --> 01:26:43,374
I did.

1612
01:26:43,458 --> 01:26:46,002
Strange, but I didn't
think about it before.

1613
01:26:46,085 --> 01:26:48,214
Well, what about the lawyer?
Why didn't he say something?

1614
01:26:48,298 --> 01:26:51,216
There are 12 people in here
concentrating on this case.

1615
01:26:51,301 --> 01:26:53,386
Eleven of us didn't think of it either.

1616
01:26:53,470 --> 01:26:56,640
Well, what about the district attorney?
Do you think he'd pull a trick like that?

1617
01:26:56,724 --> 01:26:58,600
Have her testify without her glasses?

1618
01:26:58,726 --> 01:27:02,648
Did you ever see a woman who had to wear glasses and
didn't want to because she thinks they spoil her looks?

1619
01:27:02,731 --> 01:27:06,235
Okay. She had marks on her nose.

1620
01:27:06,319 --> 01:27:09,989
I'm giving you that.
From glasses, right?

1621
01:27:10,073 --> 01:27:14,245
She didn't want to wear 'em out of the house
so people would think she's gorgeous.

1622
01:27:14,329 --> 01:27:18,916
But when she saw this kid killing his
father, she was in the house alone.

1623
01:27:18,999 --> 01:27:21,211
That's all.

1624
01:27:21,294 --> 01:27:25,299
- Do you wear glasses when you go to bed?
- No, I don't.

1625
01:27:27,010 --> 01:27:28,928
No one wears eyeglasses to bed.

1626
01:27:29,011 --> 01:27:32,015
It's logical to assume that she wasn't
wearing them when she was in bed...

1627
01:27:32,099 --> 01:27:33,851
tossing and turning, trying to fall asleep.

1628
01:27:33,935 --> 01:27:36,270
- How do you know?
- I don't know! I'm guessing.

1629
01:27:36,355 --> 01:27:38,815
I'm also guessing that she probably
didn't put her glasses on...

1630
01:27:38,898 --> 01:27:41,025
when she turned
to look casually out of the window.

1631
01:27:41,110 --> 01:27:43,863
And she herself testified the killing
took place just as she looked out.

1632
01:27:43,946 --> 01:27:46,991
The lights went off a split second later.
She couldn't have had time to put them on then.

1633
01:27:47,075 --> 01:27:48,701
- Wait a second.
- Here's another guess.

1634
01:27:48,786 --> 01:27:52,873
Maybe she honestly thought she saw the boy
kill his father. I say she only saw a blur.

1635
01:27:52,958 --> 01:27:56,544
How do you know what she saw?
How does he know all that?

1636
01:27:56,628 --> 01:27:59,381
How do you know what kind of glasses she wore?
Maybe they were sunglasses.

1637
01:27:59,464 --> 01:28:02,092
Maybe she was farsighted.
What do you know about it?

1638
01:28:02,176 --> 01:28:05,430
I only know the woman's eyesight
is in question now.

1639
01:28:05,513 --> 01:28:11,644
She had to be able to identify a person
60 feet away, at night, without glasses.

1640
01:28:11,730 --> 01:28:14,106
You can't send someone off to die
on evidence like that.

1641
01:28:14,190 --> 01:28:16,192
Oh, don't give me that.

1642
01:28:16,276 --> 01:28:18,444
Don't you think the woman
might have made a mistake?

1643
01:28:18,529 --> 01:28:20,948
- No.
- It's not possible?

1644
01:28:21,032 --> 01:28:22,658
No, it's not possible.

1645
01:28:25,620 --> 01:28:27,538
Is it possible?

1646
01:28:28,665 --> 01:28:30,334
Not guilty.

1647
01:28:34,505 --> 01:28:37,175
Do you think he's guilty?

1648
01:28:37,259 --> 01:28:39,260
I think he's guilty.

1649
01:28:42,015 --> 01:28:43,682
Do you?

1650
01:28:46,561 --> 01:28:49,606
No. I'm convinced.

1651
01:28:49,691 --> 01:28:51,275
Not guilty.

1652
01:28:51,359 --> 01:28:53,152
What's the matter with you?

1653
01:28:53,236 --> 01:28:55,154
I have a reasonable doubt now.

1654
01:28:55,238 --> 01:28:56,782
Eleven to one.

1655
01:28:56,865 --> 01:28:59,785
Well, what about all the other evidence?
What about all that stuff?

1656
01:28:59,868 --> 01:29:01,954
The knife, the whole business!

1657
01:29:02,039 --> 01:29:04,958
Well, you said we could throw out
all the other evidence.

1658
01:29:10,715 --> 01:29:12,883
Well, what do we do now?

1659
01:29:15,888 --> 01:29:17,555
You're alone.

1660
01:29:17,640 --> 01:29:21,477
I don't care whether I'm alone or not!
It's my right.

1661
01:29:24,648 --> 01:29:26,817
It's your right.

1662
01:29:35,953 --> 01:29:38,372
Well, what do you want?
I say he's guilty.

1663
01:29:40,000 --> 01:29:43,336
- We want to hear your arguments.
- I gave you my arguments.

1664
01:29:44,338 --> 01:29:46,464
We're not convinced.

1665
01:29:46,550 --> 01:29:49,344
We want to hear them again.

1666
01:29:49,428 --> 01:29:51,430
We have as much time as it takes.

1667
01:29:57,104 --> 01:30:01,566
Everything - Every single thing
that took place in that courtroom...

1668
01:30:01,650 --> 01:30:03,568
but I mean everything -
says he's guilty.

1669
01:30:03,652 --> 01:30:06,112
What do you think,
I'm an idiot or something?

1670
01:30:07,781 --> 01:30:09,868
Why don't you take that stuff
about the old man?

1671
01:30:09,952 --> 01:30:13,121
The old man who lived there
and heard everything.

1672
01:30:14,790 --> 01:30:16,459
Or this business about the knife.

1673
01:30:16,543 --> 01:30:18,544
What? 'Cause he found another one
exactly like it?

1674
01:30:18,628 --> 01:30:21,965
The old man saw him
right there on the stairs!

1675
01:30:22,050 --> 01:30:24,886
What's the difference
how many seconds it was?

1676
01:30:26,055 --> 01:30:28,055
Every single thing.

1677
01:30:29,475 --> 01:30:32,644
The knife falling through
a hole in his pocket.

1678
01:30:32,728 --> 01:30:36,066
You can't prove he didn't get to the door.

1679
01:30:36,149 --> 01:30:38,568
Sure, you can take all the time,
hobble around the room.

1680
01:30:38,651 --> 01:30:41,237
But you can't prove it!

1681
01:30:43,157 --> 01:30:46,785
And what about this business
of the el and the movies?

1682
01:30:46,871 --> 01:30:49,914
There's a phony deal
if I ever heard one.

1683
01:30:49,998 --> 01:30:54,212
I'll bet ya $5,000
I'd remember the movies I saw.

1684
01:30:54,295 --> 01:30:56,547
I'm telling ya,
everything that's gone on...

1685
01:30:56,631 --> 01:31:00,468
has been twisted and turned!

1686
01:31:00,553 --> 01:31:02,638
This business with the glasses?

1687
01:31:02,722 --> 01:31:08,269
How do you know she didn't have them on?
This woman testified in open court!

1688
01:31:08,353 --> 01:31:12,315
And what about hearing the kid yell, huh?

1689
01:31:12,400 --> 01:31:15,653
I'm telling ya, I've got
all the facts here.

1690
01:31:16,822 --> 01:31:18,698
Here. Ah...

1691
01:31:21,078 --> 01:31:23,579
Well, that's it!
That's the whole case.

1692
01:31:30,797 --> 01:31:32,381
Well?

1693
01:31:34,676 --> 01:31:36,678
Say something!

1694
01:31:41,809 --> 01:31:45,396
You lousy bunch of bleeding hearts.

1695
01:31:46,065 --> 01:31:47,983
You're not gonna intimidate me.

1696
01:31:48,067 --> 01:31:50,569
I'm entitled to my opinion.

1697
01:31:53,949 --> 01:31:58,244
Rotten kids.
You work your life out!

1698
01:32:03,085 --> 01:32:05,044
I can't keep...

1699
01:32:09,718 --> 01:32:11,386
No.

1700
01:32:15,266 --> 01:32:17,100
Not guilty.

1701
01:32:20,481 --> 01:32:22,148
Not guilty.

1702
01:32:25,152 --> 01:32:26,778
Not...

1703
01:32:37,335 --> 01:32:39,501
Um, we're ready now.

1704
01:34:33,179 --> 01:34:34,846
Hey!

1705
01:34:39,186 --> 01:34:40,852
What's your name?

1706
01:34:40,937 --> 01:34:42,438
Davis.

1707
01:34:42,522 --> 01:34:44,440
My name's McCardle.

1708
01:34:46,778 --> 01:34:48,446
Well, so long.

1709
01:34:48,529 --> 01:34:50,031
So long.


